Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: Hell
anon 2/19/12 . chapter 1
...You really don't like Rose, do you?
tkelparis 10/3/11 . chapter 1
I hadn't thought my opinion of Rose could sink any further than it had, but you managed it. Why doesn't it... surprise me...? I'm curious to know where you'd see the Doctor going after this... How his adventures would go with Rose leaving in a self-righteous huff. (Why do I want Jackie to slap her...?)
Jadziwine 4/13/11 . chapter 1
i bet you got alot of reviews saying this is OOC or Rose wouldn't be like that or this isn't really rape. but obviously those people suck. so let me clarify, that this wasn't at all out of character, Rose would totally do something like this because that was just her style of thinking, she didn't seem very capable of deeper feelings especially when you look at her relationship with Mickey. she definitely dominated his feelings, and patronized any of his deeper feelings before disregarding it. He was so easily forgotten to her, after all those years knowing each other. that when he left at journeys end. she didn't even ask where he was. so why wouldn't she just take what she wanted from the doctor when she'd been doing it for years with Mickey?
pipinheart 2/3/10 . chapter 1
Don't blame him for having the tardis lock his door. Out of control Rose...
jedimasterstar 12/17/09 . chapter 1
All I can say is - WHAT? This was very dark. And VERY good. I did not see this one coming from you (though maybe I should have - lol). Poor Doctor. I hope she does leave (though in reality she doesn't); but for her sake, she better leave him alone - something nasty may happen.

But I do enjoy seeing the wide range of reviews for this one-shot. For me, I like OOC-ness. It keeps the imagination going if one thinks about the "what ifs"; or else what fun would fanfiction really be?

And finally, Where's "Doomsday"? Hehe, just kidding. Just one silly fan wanting to see a heartbreak.
Kate Maxwell 12/15/09 . chapter 1
More reasons to hate that girl, she was just so annoying by the end of season two ( well one with 10th ) and then coming back in the fourth was just too much!

What detail you had in here, just want to push Rose into the heart of the TARDIS - though the poor ship would probably get indigestion - and hug the Doctor, though being assaulted would probably be the last thing he would have wanted!

Keep up the hate-fest!
Magali 12/12/09 . chapter 1
Good lord, you could have mentioned in the summary that it was a crack fic! And when it comes to crack, I much prefer RTD's crack! At least, he doesn't go into OOC territory.
Taylor Harkness 12/11/09 . chapter 1
Whoa! Dark!Rose there... Very alternate, I'll say, but it's really good...
WTH 12/11/09 . chapter 1
That's just sick!

Rose would never do that, it's too OOC for words... if you really think she would do that, you need to re-watch the series mate.

And for the other reviewers, she isn't a chav, she's a Londoner take it from someone who know, she doesn't act or talk like a chav and rarely - if ever, I 'spose the PK wear is slightly chavy but everybody used to waer them - dresses like one.
madeye harry 12/11/09 . chapter 1
I don't see how Rose believes the Doctor would want her to rape him. Surely she knows that rape, no matter the gender, is wrong regardless.

The fact she also did it to Mickey and the fact he thought it was actual love is just wrong. Is this a sequel to your second alternatives oneshot ? It certainly seems like it because i remember the doctor starting to fear that rose would try something. What will happen next ? What will happen next with Rose and the Doctor ? How can Rose delude herself that rape is loving ? These alternatives are fantastic because they seem to show the true nasty traits of Rose's personality, she is as many of your other reviewers have described her : a chav. But I prefer to call her a slut. Well she is.

What is the next alternative gonna be about ? Is she going to leave the Doctor and the TARDIS ?

I feel sorry for the Doctor - he has just told the Devil that he believes in Rose - now she does this. What exactly was she " celebrating " in the first place ? The hug ? it was only a hug
Donna Tempus Alena 12/11/09 . chapter 1
I can't believe Rose tried to rspe the Doctor and thought is was what he wanted! he needs to drop her off at her mom's as soon as possible.
KsandraMallan 12/11/09 . chapter 1
I've already said I can so see this happening... and in light of the trailers for "End of Time", I wish it had, as horrible as that sounds. Stupid chav. Poor darling Doctor. *Hugs him*
Return to Top