Holy Flippin! BRILLIANT!

DID MOFFAT STEAL YOUR IDEA?

Hi Just read your story it was very good. It was way better then Patrick Stewart Christmas Carol.

*Jaw hangs open in amazement* That was... brilliant. Probably the best Dr. Who fic I've seen except your X-Files crossover... I just can't find the words. Great job. BenRG's Rating 8/10

Now that ending was cool. And I loved the throw-in line from Pat-"Impossible; I'm allowed everywhere!" and the Doc's characterization was very good. And it really does make sense to give him the Christmas Carol and do it himself...

Alright, it's basically the same as *any* show's attempt to do a 'Christmas Carol' take-off and a 'show-the-miser-the-evil-of-his-ways' routine, but this one still has his charm. With a plausible 'Jacob Marley' routine (well, plausible by DOCTOR WHO standards, anyway. Given the show's basic premise, plausibility isn't a necessity), a realistic Bob Cratchit character (who, if 'Scrooge' doesn't change his way, has a bitter future ahead of him) and the Doctor makes a good Ghost of all Christmases. I saw that Patrick Stewart version as well, and loved it. How about next time, you try 'It's a Wonderful Life' - although on second thoughts, don't. Taking away all the effect the Doctor's had on the universe, that would be a bit tricky. But, I must say, despite the fact that this is retreading old ground, it's still very good.

You really do like Grace, don't you? Again, another good story.