Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: To What Can I Compare Thine Eyne?
lemonsmania 12/26/11 . chapter 1
"But if you think you can come here and infect my part of the canon..."

Haha! Mary Sues are the worst, aren't they?
Wing Commander Arnica Vinyaya 11/11/11 . chapter 1
*pouts and stomps foot in true brat style* Want Puddugwum!

Haha, nice job, Estella.
DoulosAnastasis 10/7/11 . chapter 1
Tsk, tsk, tsk...poor Eustace. And bravo, Jill!

All right; you said that humor was not your strong point, and I halfheartedly agree, because this piece - while dissecting it fully would take quite a long time, I will say that this story - had a bit too much in some places and a bit too little in others. But I do think that with a little bit of practice you could develop a more balanced composition tactic and be very, very good at writing humor pieces - I was definitely laughing aloud at this piece!
CrazyDyslexicNerd 4/20/11 . chapter 1
That's funny! And very Eustace-ish! I'd say you might add a bit more in the descriptive area, are they in England or Narnia? But otherwise very good!

-Dyslexic Nerd
Eavis 6/8/10 . chapter 1
Hah, so funny! I love Eustace's trying to complement her and (for the most part) failing miserably. And Jill to the rescue! Hurrah!

Hows about...Jewel next? With Mary-Sue trying to plait his mane and put flowers in it, and asking him why he has a beard (because everyone knows unicorns are just horses with a horn stuck on their forehead) and asking if she can ride him.

Can't wait for more!

Lion's Blessing,

Eavis
Sara Wolfe 1/10/10 . chapter 1
This was hilarious. Great start.
fledge 1/10/10 . chapter 1
Beware the Sue! And don't mix her up with Su(san). Nice little piece of silliness indeed. I have no idea why in the Narnia fandom there is such an abundance of Sues, but it's a sad fact. And of course most of them will go after also of course, they are usually less than intelligent - all their energy used up for their looks. I cant, though, for the life of me, not see what possible interaction there might be with Puddleglum - unless it's bad aim again...
Second daughter of Eve 1/9/10 . chapter 1
Hehe, it's sue Bashing, I love it!

Eve
Return to Top