Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: Ranma Palantir - Reviews: Page 1 of 2

Amenita Virosa
2005-10-04
ch 1,
abusecan u update some time VERY SOON?!?!?!?!
Silverscale
2005-04-08
ch 1,
abusePlease update your stpries, it's so sad to watch them float around like unfinished dreams.
busso
2004-06-02
ch 1, anon.
abuseJust out of curiosity, are you ever going to update this? I like it and I've been waiting for a while.
rob
2004-03-08
ch 1, anon.
abuseVery nice please continue this
Tora Tigress
2002-05-30
ch 1, anon.
abusePlease finish this story even if you don't win the second bet.
Ranko1
2002-05-23
ch 1,
abuseHuh, your view is pretty limited. But that's the wrong start. I think using one of the Palantirs as introduction is far better than the One Ring. However - who says Ranma has to stay on Earth? And who says the things in LotR have already happened? I think it'd be great to see what happened to the Fellowship of the Ring when Ranma was with them... as Gandalf's apprentice, supreme fighter and so on.
Kevin Schultz
2002-02-22
ch 1, anon.
abuseSome thoughts...well, I don't care much for the fox character (seems to be a bit of a rip-off from Metroanime with no real unique bits to make him interesting), but I find your depiction of both Gandalf and Samwise is quite good - you seem to have captured the voice of both characters fairly well.

I would personally hope for a concentration on a single crossover, rather than the mega-crossovers. LotR has a lot of stuff to use, and there's no reason to have a bunch of other crossovers simply for the sake of having a bunch of crossovers.
Lee A. Hollensteiner
2002-01-30
ch 1, anon.
abuseYou have made a good start but there is much more that needs to be done. I truly like most of your ideas and eagerly await them being written.
pcody
2002-01-27
ch 1,
abuseA worthy start, with potential depending on the direction you choose to take.

I look forward to reading later chapters.
ghost
2002-01-26
ch 1, anon.
abuselooks good i suggest a Reocrd of lodoss war crossover
Kryal
2002-01-25
ch 1, anon.
abuseHi, me again. I had a weird thought... If you DO go about making this a multi-crossover (I'm of two minds on that idea...), here's a thought: what if Pluto's Garnet Orb was really a Palantir, maybe disguised somehow. Hey, a Palantir does seem suited to being a key to the Time Gates...
spider
2002-01-25
ch 1, anon.
abuseOh this could be so good the posoblities are endless I would love to see what you could come up with
Kim
2002-01-25
ch 1, anon.
abuseInteresting...
Patrick777
2002-01-25
ch 1, anon.
abuseI really like what I've read so far. Please continue with this story. There are some wonderful opportunities here. Please try to limit the number of cross-overs as that can get too confusing to the reader.
Peter Kim
2002-01-25
ch 1, anon.
abuseI think the first thing Gandalf will do is send them to the Hobbits since he fond of the
Hobbits. Please write or update chapter 2 soon
Return to Top