|Reviews for Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality|
| bub23453 3/26/10 . chapter 8
my head hurts from all this science lol! But i LOVE seeing it in action! Keep up the good work! Why am I using exclamation mark after every sentence? No idea! :D
| LonelyAura 3/26/10 . chapter 8
XD! My mind is spinning! Anyway, awsome chapter! Hmm... could a certain girl end up in a different house? hmm..
| AnnF 3/26/10 . chapter 8
Love the last line!
| Jedi Buttercup 3/26/10 . chapter 7
OK, this I have to comment on before even reading the chapter, because after the delight of earlier it made me quail: "I am well aware of the First Law of Fanfiction stating that every change which strengthens the protagonists over canon must be matched by an equal or greater increase in their difficulties."
99% of the time, when I see people quote something like this, they unbalance it in the entire opposite direction. Some people do love angst, but some people delight in fanfics that start out like this one has because it promises a *better* outcome than canon. What's the point if it all comes out the same, or even worse?
All the same, I *have* loved it so far, so I follow onward, though much more cautiously than before...
| SituationalExtrovert 3/26/10 . chapter 1
HOLY $HIT! I already reviewed, and I just now realized that the obnoxious Gryffindor prefect has to be PERCY!
Sic 'em, Harry! SIC 'EM!
I still want to be your minion.
FYI: my niece is trying to read over my shoulder and she wants to know why I want to be your "onion". *giggle*
| Jedi Buttercup 3/26/10 . chapter 5
oh. em. gee. I just made a fool out of myself trying to keep my hysterical laughter *silent* at my desk at work. I can already tell I'll be bookmarking this one. You have a real gift.
| Stoned Koala 3/26/10 . chapter 8
And you're just summed up the greatest misconception about the scientific method. It's not that you have to try to prove your hypothesis, it's that you try to *disprove* it.
How many *real* scientists do you really think are out there?
| MrRobertsIII 3/26/10 . chapter 8
. "I make it that peculiar. You're looking at the product of a lot of hard work and elbow grease."
-Made me laugh.
| HoBoAdin 3/26/10 . chapter 8
As I'm sure you've heard any number of times by this point: this looks to be an amazing story that I cannot wait to read. This would appear to be a great story that could actually rationalize magic and still be internally consistent.
I am especially pleased that you're writing an extremely intelligent Harry without feeling the need to include out of character childish behaviors to somehow prove that Harry is actually 11.
| Shadowface 3/26/10 . chapter 8
dude, you lost it at the wandless magic.
| uiramatos 3/26/10 . chapter 8
You are a genius! At least briliant. Harry is amazing, rational to the extreme, unwilling to accept things at face value, the complete oposite of the average wizard. Your writing style is great and, to my meager knowledge of english, grammatically correct. The story flow is slow, but the scenes are very detailed and funny, witch makes itenjoyable to read.
I'm eager for the next update, and hope you do not abandon this fic,like so many authors.
| verity76 3/26/10 . chapter 8
I am loving this story. I am curious, though - are you really a first-time author? Because you are doing a rather amazing job for someone who has only one story to their screenname. Anyway, can't wait for more!
| pfeil 3/26/10 . chapter 8
I really hope you didn't interpret my comment about Draco as "MOAR PLZ!". I'm good with as little of him as possible to fulfil his role as impotent schoolyard angatonist.
Glad that Hermione will no longer be so tempted by Gryffindor. It's more of her and Harry that I want.
| ryuou 3/26/10 . chapter 8
Yay for harry, destroy the train.
| Patricka 3/26/10 . chapter 8
Can't wait until the next chapter! )