|Reviews for Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality|
| faithaholic 3/26/10 . chapter 8
Aw... poor Hermione. I sympathize though, that's how I feel after my Logic class. Awesome chapter though.
| Baughn 3/26/10 . chapter 8
That's one way to get her into ravenclaw. :)
It actually took me several days to consider that the lords of chaos might be just gred and forge, which saddens me. Well, at least I wasn't /mistaken/ on that.
And.. right, the title of the first book was "Harry Potter and the philosopher's stone", wasn't it?
The fireworks are likely to be impressive. I'm looking forward to it.
| SituationalExtrovert 3/26/10 . chapter 8
Oh, goody! Smart!Harry has morphed into KICKA$$!Harry!
Some poor Gryffindor prefect has no idea that his/her life is now - for all intents and purposes - at an ignoble end.
My cup runneth over!
On to Snape, please!
By the way, are you in need of minions? Acolytes? Sycophants? Where do I apply?
Please, mum, could we have some more?
| Zicou 3/26/10 . chapter 8
Another awesome chapter!
| acelly 3/26/10 . chapter 8
Good lord this is brilliant!
I love you and want to bear your babies! This might be a little difficult as I'm a man but I'm sure that, somehow, you'll be able to come up with a way to overcome that minor, insignificant problem. :-)
Really looking forward to the next chapter!
| Ralyn Longs 3/26/10 . chapter 8
Reading this story is a positively delightful experience. That said, I delayed reading chapter 7 so that I wouldn't have to 'tune in' for just one short chapter. But then I read that chapter 7 was 12k words, you see, so I got excited, thinking I now had 2x 12k words. But then chapter 8 was small-ish again - the inconsistency is vexing.
That is the absolute extent of my worries about this fic (well, provided you keep a fast pace - 8 chapters up to the train means either you'll be writing for years, or you'll abandon your story half-way through) - thanks for writing!
| AngelForm 3/26/10 . chapter 8
It was always slightly puzzling why The-Smartest-Girl-In-Her-Year wasn’t in Ravenclaw. On the other hand why Harry didn’t get put in with the puffs is an equally suspicious question.
I get the feeling that you have a P.H.D or two lying around.
Interesting look at the inner thought of Granger.
| gand982 3/26/10 . chapter 8
Love this story, love the treatment of Hermione. More please. Thanks for sharing.
| Allen Pitt 3/26/10 . chapter 8
Hm... and now Harry's trunk is molesting Hermione's? Maybe this is how magical trunks reproduce.
Gee, and you've got him recruiting Hermione (essential to this task, probably) and decisively turning against Gryffindor. Still-hissing like a snake? His intended destination of Ravenclaw may not be as certain as he thinks.
I have to say, his encounter with the Sorting Hat should be epic. Might drive it insane.
| odonata617 3/26/10 . chapter 8
| Mel72000 3/26/10 . chapter 8
Very great chapter, I love it !
| masterlich 3/26/10 . chapter 8
love it cant wait for the next chapter
| Arkeus 3/26/10 . chapter 8
Really like the way you are shuffling their Houses around.
Wouldn't be surprised if all three ended up in Hufflpuff, as Ravenclaw Prefect will show they don't *study* things, they just *study how to get good marks*.
| Queenofununu 3/26/10 . chapter 8
Ha! Brilliant again.
Please do not leave out the upcoming confrontation in your next chapter!
Keep up the good work.
| jtptan 3/26/10 . chapter 8
One thing, at the end, Hermione is very confused and calls the book "History: A Hogwarts" in her thoughts. While I get what you were doing there I don't know how well it actually works.
The Luna thing - I'm not sure if it's just Draco saying what he heard or what's true in this world, but it always seemed to me in the books that it was more Luna following her father in the crazy stuff rather than the other way around.
I'm glad that Harry and the Weasley twins can't have traumatized Neville *too* much if he went back to Harry & Hermione after talking to Percy, I mean, 'the mean Griffindor prefect'.