I'm sorry, I have bad English, but I'll try anyway. : D This was one of the best stories I've read: it was distressing, sad and wonderful. Immediately went to the top list of the best.

This is heart-breakingly beautiful.

I... I have no words to describe what I just read.

The cello is my favourite musical instrument... I could hear him play, I could see his face, sad - helpless - while Bella's heart hammered...

This was one beautiful piece.

Thank you for sharing.

Vraiment très beau ... Il est même difficile de trouver les mots pour exprimer l'émotion ressentie à cette lecture. Merci.

PS : Si vous aimez lire en écoutant de la musique - mettez youtube en fonctionnement et cherchez "Concierto para Quinteto - Gidon Kremer - Hommage à Piazzolla" ou "Julian Lloyd Webber - Frederick Delius - Cello Concerto".

i wish there was more chapters to this story. its such a beautiful, emotional story. i loved every part of it. it was so sad to see *read* carlisle being so sad.

Dude... that was intense! :D

But I loved it!

AMAZING WORK!

:D :D

Omg that was awesome plz update n soon!

I truly wish you would write a second part to this story. It is very well written but i wish for there to be a confronting of feelings between bella and carlisle. I hope you continue with this!

You have some serious talent. I liked the fact that there was so much emotion in this...made it even more romantic. Wow. Just wow.

Great job, I love this story so much!:)

This was amazing... so beautiful and haunting. I love it!

... okay if you don't continue this, i will virtually hit you.

that was an abosolutely amazing, words-can't-describe-how-good-it-was, breathtaking, beautifully-painful piece of writing. i LOVED your carlisle, all broody and lonesome, and the idea of clumsy bella peeping while sitting in a tree, genius. the way you described everything...i felt like i was sitting in that tree as well. really wonderful piece, Pereybere, amazing.

PS- doesn't carlisle have vampire vision/hearing? i would have expected him to see bella? :P

really wonderful job!

It's very good. I really enjoyed reading it...I nearly started crying in the library at some point-somehow i managed to stop myself though.

You could've turned this into a multi-chapter story, but it was your call. I'm not disappointed though. -

Keep it up!

Wow, this is really beautiful! Congratulations. I dearly hope you write something happier about them.

Wow, this was something completely new. I had to say I am impressed with the skills you have with this paring, what can never be is a song of tears and angst and you truly captured the tune.