Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: We Have Always Been . . . Friends
Middle of Here 3/28/08 . chapter 1
Many of the facts were incorrect (Lark came to Winding Circle when she was thirty, Rosethorn knows that she (herself) is bisexual, etc) but the story was excellent. I love the combination of Rosethorn's physical and emotional longing for her best friend (I've been there, done that), rather than just having the hots for her, and the beautiful writing. All in all, the story is amazing.
Dancing Amethyst 5/31/04 . chapter 1
Aw, weird, and totally unplausible, but very very sweet.

I must point out: Rosethorn is a plant mage, Lark is a thread mage. All their magework has to be done with either plants or thread, respectively, not raw power. Rosethorn and Lark did not meet when they were fifteen and thirteen. Lark was a traveling arcobat. She didn't even know she had magical power until she was nearly thirty. Rosethorn lived on a farm with her father, then left, was sent to mage school, then Lightsbridge, then Winding Circle. So, in canon, your whole pirate-attack-where-they-joined-power thing can't work, but it was cute, and I do so love Lark/Rosethorn fluff. Well-written, if wrong. Er, good job, I guess.

*FlamingKnight*
Snowbear 8/30/03 . chapter 1
It appears I've never reviewed this story, which is odd since I've read it millions of times and loved it each time... Well, now I'm reviewing it! And saying its a great story!
PhantomTigre 8/30/03 . chapter 1
This story is wonderful! One of my favorite Rosethorn/Lark! They're perfect together! Would you write a Rosethorn/Crane? I'm a Rosethorn fan, R/C or R/L! Doesn't matter to me!
DarkElf171 4/20/03 . chapter 1
great story hope you add to it
Darkflare 10/21/02 . chapter 1
It's good, even though I don't go in for Rosethorn/Lark
jenelin 4/30/02 . chapter 1
Wonderful and very, very Rosethorn! It feels, and feels deeply, which makes it a satisfying short piece. You've captured the essence of Rosethorn in this situation.
ME 2/9/02 . chapter 1
YOU PULLED IT OFF WELL, BUT THIS REALLY ISN'T MY SORT OF THING.
Kamatazi Yumi 2/4/02 . chapter 1
Ahhhhh... How sweet!
Silpi 2/2/02 . chapter 1
Aw, thats so sad. Its sweet, though. I liked it. :)
Bear 2/2/02 . chapter 1
That was excellent. You captured Rosethorn very well, and I liked how you developed her love for Lark. Tres bonne!

Bear

PS I'm usually pretty hard on fics, it's a rare occurence if I find one I like. And this one, I like. :D
Colorain 2/2/02 . chapter 1
W-O-W! That was great!

I mean, really, beautiful! I can see Rosethorn thinking like that, and just the writing itself was marvelous.

And you say you have writer's block . . .
Return to Top