| Reviews for But We Got Rum |
|---|
lealila 1/20/13 . chapter 1Beautiful. You captured the interactions between Alice and Cpt. Jack perfectly. Well done. |
Httw 3/13/12 . chapter 1That was lovely. Perfectly in character and not impossible to believe. I wouldn't mind seeing more of this AU, at all. |
Nerd4ever243 9/30/11 . chapter 1My two favorite movies my two favorite characters AWESOMENESS. lol I loved it for said reasons mentioned above! Ahh this is a nice litle fic and now that you mention it there is similarities to Elizabeth and Alice but I like Alice more. Keep writing you're freaking awesome! |
TiaBolt 3/16/11 . chapter 1 You've captured the essence of these characters quite nicely-Alice with her quirky elegance, and Jack with his carefully controlled madness. The last line was definitely my favorite-"tell me lovely, lovely alice..." - that is exactly what jack would say! All in all, I loved it! Definitely a favorite and I'd like to see more of their interactions. (and hear Jack's six impossible things-there are soooo many possibilities!) |
Nocturnal Smile 10/12/10 . chapter 1This weirdly makes so much sense, and you wrote it so well. Their dialogue's spot on, I'd love to see more from these two! |
PERMANENT DEACTIVATED ACCOUNT 7/20/10 . chapter 1Match made in heaven. |
ney 7/17/10 . chapter 1 I realized I had never left a review-for shame! Thank you, this catered to so many needs. I have no well rounded critique to offer except "omg u rule" spam. 3 |
Phritzie 7/9/10 . chapter 1Oh, I'm LIKING this crossover. And not for the romance- Alice and Jack share way too much in commonalities of strangitude. |
KatrinaEagle 4/18/10 . chapter 1Amazing. This is pure genius. Fantastic, wonderful, surreal... 3 |
CyanideDreams610 4/17/10 . chapter 1Oh, I love this! It would be really great if you would turn this oneshot into a chaptered story! I'd love to read more of it! |
flashily 4/15/10 . chapter 1Read this while offline, but just had to say I loved it to bits. |
xBlackRabbitx 4/2/10 . chapter 1Teehee... loved it. And plausible, too, which is nice to see, though I think they may have been set in slightly different times... Anyway, I very much enjoyed this. I do think that Alice would know what rum is, but still. Jolly good. A favourite for you. |
summerlea 3/23/10 . chapter 1 Nice! I love how well you captured tim burton's alice. They make an interesting pair. |
Watermelon Sniper 3/22/10 . chapter 1God damn, but you write well. The dialogue was amazing - very snappy, and the "interesting diction" really shines through, which a lot of writers aren't able to get down right. I like the little turns of phrase you've added into the prose, that Alice asks Jack if he believes a raven is like a writing desk - hee! - and very definitely your characterization; Alice and Jack are fantastic characters, and you did them great justice. So yes, in short, this made me happy. 33 |
aikenichi11 3/17/10 . chapter 1Oh my God! This is the first crossover Ive seen done in this fandom, and I love the way you do it. I dearly hope there will be more :) |