 Rosie 5/14/11 . chapter 1 What a charming, original concept! I'm going to read all your Squib stories! Love your writing. |
 SnapeAngel 12/16/09 . chapter 1great story |
 Mother of Tears 11/16/06 . chapter 1I love it. |
 Bagge 3/28/06 . chapter 1Nice! Filch really seems to be a decent chap when he is not seen from the students' eyes. His worrying about mrs Norris was heart warming, and I enjoy how well he and Hagrid gets along. That beach-spell Dumbledore put on Fluffy explains why the dog was content with being in that corridor as well. To bad it put focus on Filch' squibiness though... Well done! |
 Midge Magpie 1/23/05 . chapter 1M'aw!
Happy pets. :D |
 Shadowgirl1 5/10/04 . chapter 1“That creature just hit me harder than the Hogwarts Express! |
 Moriel Malkin 8/6/03 . chapter 1Delightful!
I can see I am going to enjoy this series greatly!
Thank you so very much! |
 Try 5/26/03 . chapter 1 I love your "Squib" fics, especially the shorter ones where he's just an ordinary janitor with a pet cat. |
 Nokomiss 2/23/03 . chapter 1This was wonderful! I like Filch, and you've done a marvelous job with him here. So real, his pain at being nonmagic, even at his age :( And his devotion to Mrs Norris was perfect in this! Good job! |
 MK in La La Land 2/8/03 . chapter 1Well I've finally got around to read some of your stories and their great! |
 Bitter Bathory 1/22/03 . chapter 1If somebody told me about a wonderful, Filch-centric, first person POV fic, I'd laugh. Shows how much I know.
I love the devotion and admiration he has for Mrs. Norris. In canon he's so...inaccessable, but he's very human here. And this may sound silly, but good job on Hagrid's accent. He's pretty hard to write (and read, if it's not done right!) but you pulled it off very well. |
 Hush Puppie 9/23/02 . chapter 1This was so cute . Filch, Hagrid, and even Mrs. Norris were so in-character. But at the same time, you've managed to put your own unique mark on all of them. You've managed to keep Ms. Rowling's wonderful characters and places just how they are in the books while still adopting your own writing style. An amazing feat indeed. I loved Mrs. Norris and Fluffy making friends _ This is great.
What the hell happened to Fluffy after SS/PS, anyway? |
 Katinka31 7/15/02 . chapter 1I never thought a Filch-fic would make me sniffly, but this one sure did! In such a short piece, you really highlight the ways in which he's alone in the world...in terms of his lack of family/companionship, as well as in his magical inabilities. Didn't JKR say that in a future book, someone will learn magic later in life? I'd never thought of Filch before, but it's a thought!
Filch's devotion to Mrs. Norris is surprisingly touching:
"Mrs. Norris was accustomed to going almost everywhere she wanted to go inside the castle corridors. No corridor was “Forbidden” as far as she was concerned. I’d given her stern warnings
and a very serious lecture concerning cats and the dangers of curiosity. Apparently, she’d thought I must have meant other cats."
I then had to laugh when he mentally accused Hagrid of excessiveness with *his* pets. hee hee I also liked seeing the rapport between these two men, neither of whom are "proper" wizards. Reminded me of the "Pull yourself together, man!" scene in the movie (speaking of which, I can't wait for Movie-Filch to get more screen time in CoS!).
I shall be back for more Squibness!
Katinka :) |
 anonymous 5/6/02 . chapter 1 Cute story! Hagrid doesn't appear in enough stories. |
 Blue Moon Pie 4/14/02 . chapter 1Ha! Ha! Ha! Ha! - Sagi |