4.5/5

you get only those strikes because of a few spelling mistakes and the story is very predictable. but everything else was pure gold... especially the ending that wasn't all that predictable. but it's very odd to release the Xmas episode at the dawn of august.

Nice done on the chapter, though im glad you're updating this.

keep up the good work!

YOU JUST M KNIGHT SHAMALONED MY ASS at first reading this story i thought thomas would be with emily and then at the end you made a WHAT A TWIST now i feel like watching thomas for like the rest of the day and as a critic who watches crappy movies and tv show this was the best thing i ever read.

why is emily always sad for her mom and dad SHE SEES HER DAD EVERY STINKIN DAY

it's good to see rosie again.

did henery live?

you get a feel for the characters

AWESOME IT IS THE BEST STORY I EVER READ AND I NERVER READ NOW I FEEL LIKE WATCHING THOMAS AND FRIENDS

I've wondered what happened to Brad after he was scolded... but I'm sure you know the answer to that. :) Still, a great series.

It's great to see Thomas and Emily becoming Closer together,and I saw your latest chapter,and though I know you just wnated some shots on Rosie,but I'll always love Thomas with Emily,and I'll be looking forward to your future chapters.

this is like the best birthday chapter gift ever. i nearly cry.

i'm gonna turn 19 tomorrow, so happy birthday to me!

i think u should make a chapter where arry and bert fall in loce with new twins i call them ashley and britney i really think this is a good suggestion what do u think?

Awwww, this chapter makes me have great respect for Henry. He kind of reminds me when I was ill a lot.

this is really a nice ending to misty island.

good job on it.

Hello,I just wanted to let you know that I'm enjoying your story and love for how Thomas and Emily are becomming closer together,I hope you'll put more of the story up 's getting really exciting.