Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: The Squib and The Potions Master - Reviews: Page 1 of 5

Sifauna Auria
2007-10-19
ch 1,
abusereally really good. i really enjoyed reading this. =D very different from the other fics that are out there. filch is a really under-represented character, but then again, in the books he wasn't particularly likeable, but you gave him a decent side and i like it.
Domenic
2007-10-12
ch 1,
abuseGoing on favorites.

Heh, Filch thinks Snape was too rash! XP I love impulsive!heroic Snape. XP
Freya
2007-09-18
ch 1, anon.
abuseNow i'm not usually a fan of Filch and yet this was strangely likable, being an avid fan of anything Snape i procceeded and i am glad that i did. I very much enjoyed his narrative and a Snape in canon is always a bonus.

thankyou
Mother of Tears
2006-11-16
ch 1,
abuseWonderful! I have just found you and will probably read your first stories first. This one is a gem. You've got all these characters down to every nuance. I love how you've illustrated a tiny scene from the first book from a completely novel point of view. Very few writers do Filch, but you've done him beautifully. I like how you've capture Snape too.
Daddys Morbid Little Girl
2006-09-04
ch 1,
abuseHello,
I just came across this little one-shot
and I loved it.
The ending made me crack up.
'I turned to look at The Boy Who’d Just Distracted Snape. Poor Potter. He had just gotten the full
force of Snape’s fury. And he would never know how grateful to him I was.'
Ha, poor potter, poor potter.
Anyways this was very good, keep it up.

~Beautifully Tainted~
Merlin's trash can
2006-07-30
ch 1,
abuseI love this story. You write very well. I'll never think of Filch in the same way again.
magdilen
2006-05-16
ch 1,
abusegood story- blends well with the book, and everyone's in character.
Bagge
2006-03-28
ch 1,
abuseFilch actually cares in his own, special way. It was nice to see him gently guide the highly independent Snape towards admitting that he actually could use a helping hand. Good character portraits, and a nice ending in canon.

"He saw what I knew, quite plainly in my face." - or in his eyes, perhaps. Legimancy has many uses.

"The Boy Who’d Just Distracted Snape" - easely a braver feat then merely being "The boy who lived ;-)
FireChildSlytherin5
2006-03-12
ch 1,
abuseLike it. I laughed at some places. hehe *laughter echoed*
whitehound
2005-10-21
ch 1,
abuseMarvellous!
Taintless
2005-10-09
ch 1,
abuseGreat POV, and very interesting! I enjoyed it! Great writing, and funny in parts.
Possum132
2005-08-30
ch 1,
abuseI find your Squib universe really compelling.
Dr. Embattledcurve
2005-08-19
ch 1,
abusevery enlightening.
Cora-leanna
2005-06-17
ch 1,
abuseOh I liked that! "the-boy-who-just-distracted-snape eh? that was good! Interesting to see things from Filch's side. hope to see more with filth and snape!
Shading in Grey
2005-05-14
ch 1,
abuseYou are really good at capturing the characters - Snape sounds perfectly Snape-ish, and I love the way Filch relates his glares, etc., to cleaning - it's the perfectly fitting thing for him to do.
This is very well-written, thank you for sharing. I love this.
Return to Top