Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Aragorn vs. Mary Sue - Page 1 of 3
SickleYield
2005-10-03 . chapter 1
Very funny. And good point.
JennyJoy4
2005-06-05 . chapter 1
Heh. Good one.
I never thought about it, but Arwen/Luthien, in her absolute elf-wisdom, beauty, skill and just over-all perfect, really is a bit of a Mary-Sue...
I guess that's what you get for being based off of the author's wife!
Alekey The Hobbitelf
2005-01-22 . chapter 1
That was pro. I'm in shock. I never looked at Arwen that way, Although it's true she didn't really do anything for the whole trilogy SHE REPLACED MY SWEET GLORFINDEL!SHE MUST PAY!Thank-you for (in a way) making her pay
Br0wn3yedGirl
2004-06-28 . chapter 1
Wow. I HATE Arwen! lol. this was pretty damn hysterical. I enjoyed it.

})i({Danielle})i({
Night Genie
2004-06-25 . chapter 1
lol, very good!
Goddess-of-da-Cheeseburgers
2004-05-28 . chapter 1
DEATH TO MARY-SUES! *evil grin* MWUWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA...HAHA...hah! *pulls out the soda bottle of DOOM*
Rose Angel
2004-04-16 . chapter 1
http://w.fanfiction.net/read.php?storyid=1379917
Arwen didn't just sit around, there are better things in life then fighting after all.
Aine Tassorosso
2004-01-01 . chapter 1
This story is fairly funny and I only have one nitpick in that the singular of Dunedain is Dunadan, not Dunedan. I would apprieciate it if you changed this; having Aragorn tell Mary Sue off for using the wrong term and then doing it itself is rather annoying to the reader.
Tsumina
2003-12-20 . chapter 1
Five Tsumina Stars for this story! Yay! It's really funny, and I'm glad to see that someone actually READ the book before writing a fanfic. Some people...*sigh*...they think they know everything after they've seen the movie, though half of it is a lie. I like the movie though. It's good. I'm glad someone knows that Arwen did close to nothing and if everything concerning her in the book were to be compiled, it would take less than a page. She DID sit on her butt the entire time and did nothing. I'm glad you pointed that out. I'm also glad she's dead. Okay, continue writing. I enjoy your stories.
arwentheelf02
2003-10-23 . chapter 1
ROTFL! THAT WAS AMAZING!

God I hate mary sues dont you? I flamed one and she (the author) got all defensive...
^_^
2003-08-18 . chapter 1
Yes! Death to Arwen! Stupid git messes up all the prefectly good slash.
Miz Zag
2003-08-18 . chapter 1
Amusing, but I think you'll be flamed by Arwen fans. *peeks at the other reviews* Am I right?
jessica
2003-03-23 . chapter 1
hello, good story...i hate mary sues
AnyaAnanda
2003-01-27 . chapter 1
you're cracked, it was intresting though
Annoying Took
2003-01-21 . chapter 1
cute! i liked the first part particularly
Return to Top