Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: Perfect in Weakness
Silver Ash 2/15/11 . chapter 1
I liked the question that Sailor Moon asked Tuxedo Mask. That was worth reading the story- and your summary definitely drew me into the story. I also liked the set up for the story. The first paragraph was my favorite, with the talk of time spent and excuses made. Overall I liked your attitude for Sailor Moon much better than shown in the US anime.

Nicely done. Keep writing!
Godschildtweety 11/12/10 . chapter 1
Great story
Hikari Urania 7/24/10 . chapter 1
AWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW! Adorable!
Amydali86 6/3/10 . chapter 1
great
Azurite 5/30/10 . chapter 1
Interesting! It's not often you see first season romances (these days) that take place during that timeframe before Jupiter joined and the Rainbow Crystals threw everything into confusion. The reference to a kiss (presumably, Tuxedo Mask was thinking of Usagi?) is what I'm assuming deals with your other fic, so it piqued my curiosity enough to probably go and read it (sneaky sneaky)!

It caught my attention that you called the Senshi "scouts" in this, even though you use the Japanese names. I suppose if you didn't want to use Japanese, you could always say "Sailor Soldiers," which is probably the most popular translation, or the more official "Sailor Guardian," now that the series has been re-released with that name (well, "Pretty Guardian," but close enough). I'm one of those folks who can appreciate a word being translated when a translation exists, but for some reason "Scout" just never sat well with me, even though I grew up with the dub.

There were a few grammar SNAFUs here and there, but nothing critical, just the usage of a comma inside dialogue before attribution (that is, it should look something like this: "We're finished," Mercury said.) and one instance of a misplaced apostrophe (Tuxedo Mask's, rather than Masks', since he's the only caped crusader in a mask helping the girls out, and he only wears the one mask).

Overall, a good job-the question and answer were surprising! It's fun the kind of stuff we fans imagine Usagi / Sailor Moon might ask anyone after unwillingly getting used to her new role as savior of the world. She's a pretty amazing character, and I think this little ficlet captured her personality, as you said, "perfect in weakness."
James Birdsong 5/30/10 . chapter 1
Cool. Maybe cute. :)
Return to Top