Great story! You wrote every character very well. I especially liked the interactions between Sam, Dean, and Jimmy/Castiel. Also Jimmy's relationship with Amelia was absolutely adorable! Wonderful job!

I really liked this fic and the original. Really really liked. Do you still write? Post somewhere else? Please let me know _

Nice! I liked how you showed Jimmy and Castiel as separate people, and how they had their own interactions with John, Dean, Sammy, and then Amelia and Deirdre. I got a bit confused about the boys ages. So does Castiel still know what happened in Jimmy's original life and is just hiding it from Jimmy, or did he remove it/make himself forget somehow?

This is a truly amazing story, and I'm so glad I found it! The interactions between Jimmy and Castiel just seem so real and heartfelt, and I love that Castiel is able to finally have some measure of happiness and belong to a family. The end was probably my favorite part! I loved every part of the story though, so thanks for writing it!

This fic was absolutely amazing. Beautiful and moving and very well written. I love the idea of Cas somehow becoming a Winchester, it's my favorite AU. Thank you for writing this and please continue it! :)

This is AMAZING! I particularly love the exchange between John and Cas at the end of the last chapter, but this whole story is fantastic! I would love to read more in this universe!

Oh my God, I love this story! I love how you wrote the characters. They're all so... them, so believable. LOVELOVELOVELOVE! 3

_

Up to Chapter 2. Can't wait for the next chapter _

It was written fantastically.

I did notice one thing. I may have read it wrong though:

'...that he had failed his family to utterly and completely.' - should it be too utterly, or so utterly?

To chapter 3! XD

This is a great story, and I like how Jimmy and Castiel is the same, and that Jimmy actually is in control

I've only got two things to say since I find myself speechless: EPIC, GOLD & TOTALLY IN "THE BOOK". Bravo. :D

This was so superfantastic that I can't even come up with words to express it. Please know that this had me entranced and it moved parts of me that even the /show/ never has. Good go-sh ;D

Loved this. Amazing

Holly. Freakin. Wow. Just... wow. This was stunningly beautiful. Please tell me there will be more of this.

I LOVED this story! 5*s