| Reviews for Without the Stars |
|---|
daisymall13 2/18/10 . chapter 3*sniff* sad ending :( awesome story though (yes I know this is eight years late but... it makes it 90 reviews!) |
Mandanza 3/7/08 . chapter 3It surprised me that he died, actually. But it was well written, and it moved me. Both sad and beautiful. For some reason, beauty and sadness goes hand-in-hand in these kinds of fics. |
spiritstallion 5/21/07 . chapter 3This is very good. I loved how Legolas gave his life for the fellowship. I want another story from you! |
spiritstallion 5/21/07 . chapter 2I hope Legolas will be okay! |
spiritstallion 5/21/07 . chapter 1I really like this! Poor Legolas that must hurt! |
fearlesschildofGod 6/23/06 . chapter 3*sniff* That was so sad..and beautiful..Keep up the good work :) |
White Wolf1 1/28/06 . chapter 3A really touching story of self-sacrifice for the good of others. And by doing what he did, Legolas saved not only his friends but all of Middle-earth, as well. Loved the ending - A star. Nicely done. |
nautika 1/7/06 . chapter 3You made me cry. I hate death fics and definitely avoid them, but I think I'll forgive you because his sacrifice was so noble. |
avalonmage 5/9/05 . chapter 3y did u kill legolas |
raspberry 4/28/05 . chapter 3 Balrog. Orcs. And it's knives, dammit! *weeps despondently* Please read the books. Please! |
Jedi-Bant 10/13/04 . chapter 3I have read this so many times and it still makes me cry. The ending is so beautiful. lov JEDI_BANT |
MoroTheWolfGod 2/13/04 . chapter 3By the Goddess that was neat. Reminds me of DragonHeart. |
NinielB 2/12/04 . chapter 3Nice one... Please write a sequel, this is truely good and I'd love to read more... You coldn't possibly have the Valar take pity on his sacrifice and give him back to middle-eath b/c he has an unfinished task to complete, like Glorfindel... and Gandalf (in the movie) I LOVE daeth fic's, they are so emmotional, but then again I hate them b/c they stop a life of someone I really love... |
Firestorm 1/26/04 . chapter 3This was a very sad story, and yet good as well. In a way it felt like I was there, feeling as if I had lost him as well, though Legolas is a fictional character. My applaud to you. |
Gozilla 1/25/04 . chapter 3So sad... yet so good! You are one of the greatest writer I have ever seen! Thanks for writing! - |