A great story. Very well written.

Why did they have to die? But it was beautiful all the same.

Your writing is beautiful, but your story is too sad.

This is...amazing. So beautiful, so agonizingly, despairingly beautiful...

It's that kind, the sadness that does not so much wrench your heart or make you cry as the sadness that makes you stare, reread, almost want to weep though no tears come...

...the kind that makes you wax poetic in a review...

Ah! Very well-written, but why did you have to do that? They deserve what happy endings they can get, and this definitely wasn't one!

Fantastich!

I, ph6fingeredman, am once more leaving nothing but a review consisting entirely of varying themes on, "SQUE! TEH AWESOME!11!1!1!1!"

The blame, however, lies entirely with you. If you made a mistake once in a while I could leave a proper review, but /no/ your fics have to be flawless every single time. Spoilsport.

Beautiful...*starts sobbing*

Oh, this fic is so sad. I can't tell you how much I love your work. Your writing is so very moving and passionate. Your "Raven's Song" had me bawling, literally. This was yet another LOTR gem. I hope you keep writing Legolas/Gimli. (Yes, I don't care that you said it's just a friendship fic. Sure...) :P

Definitely had me teared up there. Short, but wonderful. Magnificent job.

hey,

loved this, it was so well written and it just completely entranced me

thanks for the review, i appreciate it, i didnt know that about Elves, so thanks, phew, i got some explaining to do, lol, wonderful story here, amazing.

Beautiful and sad. I loved it.
Keep up the brilliant work.
cat

The moment I finish re-applying my mascara I read this. I am now typing this with black tears running down your cheeks. And it's all your fault. *evil glare*

This was stunning. Stunningly awful and stunning ly beautiful. Arrgh... I will creep away now and cilng to my happy ending for these two. After I cast about blindly for the kleenex box. I cannot see right now.

Nice, but sad. *sniffs*

*Andy promptly bursts into tears*

That was so beautiful! And terribly, terribly sad at the same time. The Sea is a heartless thing, indeed. Poor Legolas! Poor Gimli!