Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: The Good Soldier
Fin Tuscany 8/3/02 . chapter 1
Poignant. I liked the butterfly imagery. I also liked the way Ben is addressed at the start of each of the first 3 stanzas, by name, as 'brother,' and by designation. It added to the resonance of the piece, and also described the different roles Ben would have had to play in his life (who knows, maybe that also added to the load that pushed him over the edge?). Thanks for writing it.
Psycho Goddess 5/9/02 . chapter 1
sombre-I like it:)You kept well with the emotions of the episode
gilenagile 4/15/02 . chapter 1
You really bring out Ben's fear of the unknown and inability to cope with reality. This poem relates just as well to HG as to PL.
catherder 2/27/02 . chapter 1
As usual, your poetry brought tears to my eyes. I love the image of the butterfly, so beautiful, so ephemeral. Just like Ben.
pari106 2/27/02 . chapter 1
Very nice :) Thank you.
Ashantai 2/27/02 . chapter 1
Loved it, loved it, loved it. This was an amazing, wonderful description of Ben, of Max's thoughts on Ben.

I love Ben. He's a sensitive issue for me. I miss him. This made me cry but it's so good, and you really seem to have the exact same thoughts about Ben as me- "They were all butterfly shadows on the wall." "But you had your own nomlie - It grew inside you." "You’re in the good place Where no-one ever gets punished..."

Amazing, amazing lines and they reflect exactly how I see 'crazy, beautiful Ben.' You hit the nail right on the head, so to speak, and created a very powerful, very moving poem in the process. Thanks for helping keep Ben's memory alive, because the show certainly hasn't.

Keep up the awesome work, Kasman! I really love your stuff, especially this and your Tinga pieces, which are all on my favourites list. I'm adding this next! :)
Mija 2/26/02 . chapter 1
That was really good. It shows the good side that Ben did have at one time.
JoJo 2/26/02 . chapter 1
That was good. I really liked it. _
Kyre 2/26/02 . chapter 1
Well, I already told you what I thought, but I figured I'd leave a word and bump up your review count. :)
AlidaJester 2/26/02 . chapter 1
Very good.

After reading it at least twice I think this is my favourite line:

"Like a butterfly on gilded wings."
ReadsAllTheTimeButIsNotRegistered 2/26/02 . chapter 1
yah! i think im the first one to review, plus this is my first review ever!

this is great; short and really sweet.
kellyem 2/26/02 . chapter 1
lovely poem. very sad.
Return to Top