 KrnYong 8/26/11 . chapter 15So beautiful and poignant... You are a very gifted writer!
There are few stories that can manage to be so sad and dark, yet hopeful and bright at the same time. I applaud you *clap clap* |
 pawakin 3/30/11 . chapter 3minorly confused, explain please? |
 2stupid 9/19/10 . chapter 14...I cried. |
 anon 6/17/10 . chapter 2 Generally, if one "lifts their glance from the sky," they wind up bent over backwards...
But I like. I very much like. 's a good concept. Better than many I've seen. |
 anon 5/5/10 . chapter 3 You know, it's funny, I was just reading about that today.
Poor Legolas. Though it'd be kind of funny is Thranduil just accidentally fell out. XD |
 Amadoni 7/21/08 . chapter 15Incredible. Brilliant. Spell-bindingly creative. |
 Iryana 4/1/08 . chapter 15Wow.
Wow.
This story is utterly amazing. I'm just speechless right now. The emotions are just so raw... I feel terribly depressed right now. Wonderful job! |
 RumorUnderOath 3/7/07 . chapter 15wow, omg, wow this is awsome! i loved it! its sad, and almost morbid death giveing over to life. and all the other races fading, but with hope found in the end. very nice. fave! |
 dancingkatz 6/22/06 . chapter 15I feel the same now as I did the first time I sat down and read The Silmarillion. Heart-sore and Heart-glad at the same time. This tale is utterly soul-rending and I can't imagine anyone being unmoved by it.
I noticed various times throughout reading some odd wordings but they didn't distract me or take away from the experience of the story. I have added this to my favorites list and will most definitely re-read it.
Thank you.
Dancingkatz |
 GabrielSilk 1/18/06 . chapter 15Oh wow oh wow oh wow! THAT IS A REALLY REALLY CLASS STORY! I love it i love it i love it! MORE! There is a elf inside me i know that coz i want to be an elf! |
 Unsung Heroine 5/27/05 . chapter 15I am... speechless. Utterly, endlessly, unbelievingly speechless. Seriously unable to utter what I want to say now. This is... wow. Simply 'wow'. How come I didn't find this earlier?
Goes on my favorites list... |
 duj 3/12/05 . chapter 15Haunting. |
 thePhantom'sEvenstar 9/12/04 . chapter 15This story is beyond amazing to the point where I almost don't know what to say (well, almost)! It is so deep and so realistic, so full of raw fear and diminished hope. I have never read anything, whether it be a novel or fanfic, remotely like this- it's so unbelievebly and unimaginably fantastic. A tale of beautiful darkness. It flows with such an understanding it almost seems like a poem. Wonderfuly splendid job of writing about
death among the fairest. It seriuosly sounds like something Tolkien himself would write! Keep it up! |
 Lady Russell Holmes 4/22/04 . chapter 15I still have no words. This is too... filling a story. It leaves no space in my heart for speculation. |
 The Wolf's Pen 4/20/04 . chapter 15Good story, one of the best in Fanfiction. |