 WatsonandMary4ever 4/8/12 . chapter 1A great story. Very well written. |
 Elfgirl2005 9/28/02 . chapter 1Wow, i really liked this. One of the most amazing things about Lotr is Aragorn and Arwen's love. That must've been so hard for Elrond to watch! Wow, you wrote that really well. Great Job! |
 Lady Cheshire 8/15/02 . chapter 1So sweet and sad. I'm always touched by the bond between Elrond and Arwen, and you've captured his sorrow and angst so well here. Major kudos.
Thanks for the fic. |
 Soledad 3/3/02 . chapter 1Wonderful. And so in character. We need more Elrond stories like this. |
 Sorne 3/2/02 . chapter 1Snnniiiiffff! Poor Elrond. Great little piece. |