What the...? How could you write something so awful about the characters? You make me so sad. This is one of my favorite books, and to want the characters to all die is something horrible to want.

Well it's good, and the style was nice, but the fact that you don't like the book spoils it quite a lot...

This was pretty good...but how can your class hate Skellig! I just finished reading it last night and loved it. I watched the movie first. But great story line.

I remember reading skellig. interesting one shot, very well written :D ...I read the mini story summary (along with your one shot) and I'm left wondering why you don't like the book when you write so well? I realize the book isn't for everyone, but is there some particular reason you did what you did (don't wanna give away spoilers...) in your story?

Either way, keep writing. You're good at it.