I was beginning to have my suspicions halfway through

That was great. That was so great. Although it probably isn't the reaction you would like, I couldn't help but laugh. That was definitely an interesting take on something I thought I knew.

Never in my life have I read a fanfiction so amazingly unique. In other words: WOW! OMG, YOU'RE SO AWESOME!

I loved it! I had no idea where the story was going at first, but the end there was great! And mind-blowing!

That was really enjoyable and very different.

Ah, I didn't figure out till it mentioned his squashed face...pathetic, right? Then again it's late, and we can't all be good at deductions like Crookshanks, eh?

Brilliant as usual though. Your writing is a breath of fresh air for some reason...

Holy crap you have the most awesome and unique ideas. Wow. That was awesome!

I got it at XI...

Wow. That was really weird. And interesting.

Fascinating. Absolutely intriguing. Masterfully written, of course, and yet, what really gets me is the idea that Crookshanks has a past. I suppose it's not something many people think about, but really, all the possibilities inherent in that one small idea...fabulous.

As always, a pleasure to read.

Love,

Avalon

It was crookshanks? Da fuuuuuqqqqqqq. I should probably work on my Harry potter knowledge though. This was really well written, write more!

Hi! I didn't figure it out until the first sentence in XII .

Thank you for this story, even though it is very sad. To quote a favorite movie of mine, "We all died a little in that damned war."

EXCELLENT. I may love Animagus!Crookshanks. I also may love you on account of how you write the best stories.

I figured out it was him in the first paragraph of VIII. Before then I was deeply, deeply confused because I did not recall there being a HP character matching the description you gave.

I also briefly thought that Amelia's last name was Bones, although on second thought she was in the wrong generation for that.

Thought so at the second paragraph. XD Then scrolled down and realized that yes, I was right.

Okay, I have a confession. After reading this story, I subconsciously checked the reviews page to make sure I wasn't the stupid one or anything. xD However, I got it pretty fast. Right when the main character decided to be an Animagus in VI. An Investigator, I had an inkling. I was 100% sure when the description of the ginger fur and the squashed face came up. But at first I thought it was Lupin or Tom Riddle Jr. :P

Amazing story once again, Speechwriter. I've actually wondered about Crookshanks being an Animagus, even after Jo vetoed it. It would make such an interesting story - as you proved!

Keep writing! (:

That was really cool - the idea of having Crookshanks be an animagus trying to kill Peter was very creative.