 Red Tale 2/23/05 . chapter 1This story has a lot of potential...and considering how rushed it is it does quite a bit. I don't have a problem with slash but the OOC stuff messed it up (out of character). I think you captured something about Al but missed Sam completely, which sort of throws the story off. People are allowed to change their lives around (ie, have Sam and AL living together and whatnot), but when you're doing so much changing around you need to really make sure you're on the mark.
Also, with the rushedness I sometimes key parts of the story because they were buried. Better grammer and punctuation might help with that.
I'm assuming that since so much effort had to be put into this story that you will appreciate the serious reviews. But...when you're getting a lot of negative reviews or flames, its something to pay attention too, not that you have to be at everyone's whim but just as an author you can see what people had problems with. |
 xfphile 4/18/02 . chapter 1This is one of the worst stories I've ever stumbled through. The plotline, while intriguing, was so poorly thought out and written that I can't
tell anyone what it was really about. The grammar was atrocious, the characterization was off, especially on Sam's part, and as a whole, it was unreadable, at least for me. You should find a good beta reader-and then get a gamma reader, too, just in case. If this *has* been beta'd, he should be fired.
This story has promise, but it needs a lot of work, polish, care. I tried to read this when you posted it to the QLSA, but couldn't. I tried again
here with the hope that you had improved. Don't take this as a flame, but please consider what I'm
telling you. Simply cleaning up the grammar and punctuation will help this story out tremendously,
and I say that as a writer. Don't *stop* writing because someone criticized your work; make it better. Again, as a writer, I understand why that can be difficult. It's necessary, however, if you want to become a better author. Good luck. |