| Reviews for A Greenvale Christmas Tale |
|---|
M 5/20/13 . chapter 3 Awww, this is so cute! Hilarious and completely fitting for the game. I love the lunch scenes in it and the dynamic between York, Emily, and George, so this was a real treat to read. You completely nailed their characterizations, and I love their physical descriptions. OMG, York, so oblivious at the end. But that totally fits him! Y/E is a new favorite couple of mine, and you got their interaction down perfectly. And George! A ending. I love this; thank you so much for sharing it :) |
Andy Chu 5/12/12 . chapter 3I must say, this is one finely written fic about York and Emily, I don't know about what you said in the first chapter about it being sloppy and what not, because it didn't seem like that to me at all lol. As for this chapter with the mistletoe incident and all, I could actually see this happening in the game... if the game had a Christmas. I agree with what you say about the couple at the note, and would also like to add that imo, Emily is one hot lady. I'm a bit at odd's end about what you meant when you said "And the fact that it's portrayed so maturely", could you explain this a bit more? Anyways, I loved this little side story, thanks. |
Davewik 4/26/12 . chapter 3Ah how lovely :-) I've just finished playing through the game for the second time after leaving it for about a year, and it hasn't failed to enraptue me again. There is just something transcendent about it isn't there! Perfect depiction of York, he would've had no clue what she was on about...until you had been driving about town for a few miles! Long live Deadly Prem :-D |
Foxgirl2501 4/15/12 . chapter 3Fantastic story! I believe you pulled the characters and the humor off perfectly. I wish something like this happened in the game! |
James Birdsong 10/17/11 . chapter 3 Excellent story of course. |
Vampuric Spider 12/11/10 . chapter 3All I can say is wow. That was a wonderful story. I especially loved the humor. It was so good. That if there was a Christmas scene in the game this would be what happens. I love the snowman and the cookbook. |
Ivory Tears 12/5/10 . chapter 3I loved the way it ended. I can picture snowman George perfectly. ;) Too bad York is too dense to notice Emily's interest, that would have been a sweet scene. I really enjoyed the banter between the two, and I especially liked the card game scene. :) I hope you write another with Emily and York. |