 ain't nobody home 11/6/04 . chapter 1This is absolutely wonderful. You've done really well showing Ungoliant's nature...her ravenous anger comes across beautifully. |
 lilia 6/14/03 . chapter 1 creepy and dark fic, very interesting POV... keep going! |
 Honesty 3/22/03 . chapter 1Beautifully dark, this. Gotta love Ungoliant - though for some reason you made me feel somewhat sorry for her.
V nice, anyway. |
 GreyLadyBast 11/21/02 . chapter 1whoa, and whoa, and whoa again! This is awesome, creepy in tone and oh, so very evil! Thoroughly enjoyable.
I particullarly love this because I am a big fan of the Spiders. I only just finished reading Ungoliant's story, so it's nice to see more of her.
Obligatory plug-if you're interested, since you like the Spiders, too, you might like reading my story "Daughter of Ungoliant". Three guesses who it's about. -end plug
Again, a dark, creepy, very cool fic. Nice work. |
 Aezy 11/19/02 . chapter 1 *faints*...*gets up again* This is not only a sign that Eru exists but he loves his children aswell! Amazing! Wonderful! More of those horrid writer of MS and the like should read this and take tips! Out of the pools of slimely and slushyness comes people like you with fics like this. Well done, you are the best writer I have seen for weeks. Write more Sil fics.
They suit you.
Aezy *still oeverawed* |
 Maureen Lycaon 11/19/02 . chapter 1 What they said.:-) This is a real gem; it would grace the Tolkien_Darkfic and Silmarillion lists beautifully, and it's even on a level with the quality of Bellatrys' snippets (which I thought no one could equal).
If I have any criticism, it is this: the final paragraph *might* be better set off by itself, with a three-line break. That's because there's a lapse of time between the rest of the story and it, which I feel needs expression.
But in any case, a brilliant, brilliant piece of work! |
 Thalia Weaver 11/19/02 . chapter 1o.O this is amazing...really...*is speechless*
This is awesome! And creepy! You really get into Ungoliant's mind, which is frightening, but immensely cool.
-Thalia |
 Sunsong 11/18/02 . chapter 1Brilliant! |
 Mouse 10/7/02 . chapter 1I've been meaning to read this for a while now, and I'm so glad I finally got around to it. Awesome! You give Ungoliant such character- she had me cackling in evil delight. So many good lines- "There is no lord of the darkness, only a Queen. I created it. I have devoured the light..." "The darkness folds around me like a cape, and while it oppresses you, it feeds me." She truly is darkness itself, like a black hole sucking everything in. I particularly like how you mention that Morgoth's cry pleases her, swelling her sense of power. Then the end, with the Light burning through her dark webs. Her hunger is now for revenge... "You have cheated me."
Pure exellence. I hope you write more Silmarillion fics! |
 finch 8/15/02 . chapter 1 Yes, Morgoth seems small and weak in malice compared to Ungoliant, who IS darkness and will not stoop secretly to the light. A good portrayal of total evil. |
 Tyellas 8/13/02 . chapter 1 I loved this. What a wonderful voice of evil and power you've given Ungoliant! Very well written - keep us posted. |
 Kielle 6/12/02 . chapter 1*raised eyebrows* WOW. I didn't expect to find something like THAT on ! Very, VERY good - eloquent yet simple with a driving anger behind it that works very well. And the final paragraph is perfect. Great work! More, please! |
 Soledad too lazy to log in 3/27/02 . chapter 1 Stunning! I can't remember having read anything in this topic yet, and your portrayal of evil is so excellent, it could give a person nightmares. You should not make your allies mad at you, as we can see, especially, when they can do nasty things to you! |
 Nanjo Koji 3/20/02 . chapter 1My. Ungoliant is evil *_*... But hey, those two pretty much get what they deserve. Brilliant from the Spider witch's perspective. |