i've read this more times then i can count and every time i end up crying...because i'm a major scogue fan and them doing that just sends shivers up my spine i wish you changed it a little to make it longer but it's good this way...hope you write another story and i couldn't help but think of what you could do with a sequel for Rogue and Scott in heaven or something... things like that i honestly think you have the potential to do it hope you just think about it...

The idea of this story was good, but it went too fast... I think it would have been much better if it was drawn out. It needs more... emotion. You dont really /feel/ whats going on...

Whoa, that was great! And you said this wasnt your first language? God, I wish I could be as good in French as you are in English, make my teacher ease up a bit on my, lol.

This was wonderfully done, though I don't really like to think of Logan as a rapist or tha Scott killed him or that all three died in the end *shudder*. This was really good.

-Ice Lynx

what a sad story! well, at least scott and marie can be together in heaven. i hope to see more scott/marie fics, but please make them happier. if you ever have the time, can you read my x-men:evolution fic? if do so, thanks! .

Depressing, but really well written!

Great story. The ending was AWESOME! I like the ideal of all three of those dying...strangely did a good job even if Logan would NEVER rape or hurt Rogue, even in his animal half. You write well even if i didn't like the suject matter.

Angel

Wow. Another very strong piece. You always seem to leave things sort of under-stated, but it really makes the stories that much better.

A little confusing at times, but beautifully sad. Good writing.

Wow! I just read this I loved it. An unhappy ending great idea. Keep it up. I hope to read more from you.

dude it is dark and really good