|Reviews for A Mirkwood Elf in Dumbledore's Court|
| Graycalls 7/12/06 . chapter 4
On another note, people have asked about Elven-magic. Tolkien *does* specifically say that Elves are magical, but their powers seem to vary; for example, Elrond can control the river in his valley, Galadriel can see the future, and so on.
um those are the Three Elven Rings...
| Kelsey Estel the TolkieNarnian 7/1/06 . chapter 16
The last entry to "Mirkwood Elf" as of 09-04-02
" It's a cliffhanger, folks! Tune in, in the not-so-distant, possibly foreseeable, less-than-two-months-future for the exciting adventures of A Mirkwood Elf in Dumbledore's Court!"
Todays date 07-01-06. Less than two months? Try close to four years.
This is a wonderful story! Why haven't you updated in so long?
My theory on this is that these house-elves are those who did not sail for Valinor after the death of Elessar. He and his line could protect the elves, but afterwards, men enslaved them, and turned them into these beings, much as Morgoth turned elves into orcs. The whomping Willow probably knows of elves from tales passed down from tree to tree. Her kind of Willow most likely comes from Fangorn Forest near Rohan, or quite possibly the Old Forest on the borders of Buckland (Old-Man Willow?)
And, as for how Legolas got to Hogwarts... well, Illuvatar would not forget his beloved firstborn, no matter how long ago they had forgotten him.
Please, if you are still interested in fanfiction, give us the next chapter in this story. I do recall that you promised to finish and would not abandon us.
| Kelsey Estel the TolkieNarnian 7/1/06 . chapter 6
No, you were right, the name of the star is Earendil.
Earendil was the father of Lord Elrond. In the first age, he built a ship and sailed for valinor, wanting to ask the Valar for help in the war against Morgoth. Then, Feanor's Sons attacked the elves in their search for the Silmaril. His wife, Earwing, was able to bring the jewel to him. Now, the star of Earendil is the actual Silmaril worn upon his brow in his ship in the sky.
Elendil was the father of Isildur, Aragorn's ancestor, and one of the last Kings of Gondor who was killed in the second age fighting Sauron at Mordor.
So tell your beta-reader she was right! (You can trust the Tolkienarnian on these things!)
| Emi-Bum 6/3/06 . chapter 16
Hey, this story is one of the best i have ever read and i can't wait till you update. please update soon.
| Whilemina J. Farnsworth III 5/29/06 . chapter 1
wow. * rolls on floor laughing *
no, there's no posible way your writing sucks.
i love the poetic nature of the majority of it, and then the last line.
i also read Brothers In Arms, but i won't review that here.
| openwindow 4/23/06 . chapter 16
I LOVE YOUR STORY!
| Fuzzy Freak 4/17/06 . chapter 16
What has it been? 4 years? Are you dead or something, I must say that this is one of the fanfics that I keep checking one since it is so good, and what do I see? 4 years without an update1 ARG!
Please! Just finish...
I love Legolas, I need to know what happens to him!
| E.Tphonehome 3/19/06 . chapter 16
Wa, that was a realy EVIL evil cliffy. *pouts*
make the next chapter soon ok? by the way i love how you have portrayed legolas its so much more fun when he has a spark of mischief in him _ i cant wait till he starts freeing the other house elves _
| Shadow Elrondsell 3/6/06 . chapter 16
Hey write the next cahppie. I ought tom warn yoou that my temper reads 10 on a scale of 1 to 5! And your story is so goodmy temper may read 15 if you don't post!
| Starlit jewel 2/17/06 . chapter 6
Sigh. No, you were right the first time. Elendil is Isildur and Anarion's father. Earendil is Elrond and Elros's father who sails Vingilot across the skys. He has the Simaril bound upon his brow which is so bright that the elves call it a star. Call the star Earendil. If the star's real name is Elendil, which I don't think it is, but if it is, for goodness sakes! No one will know what you are saying. For example, if you were to talk about the Valacirya (or is it Valacirca?)I would know what you were talking about ...and you get the point.
Besides that, this really is a good story. Please update!
| BoggartBait04 2/9/06 . chapter 16
Not so distant future? It's been 4 years sence you updated this fic.
| gwynhefar 1/15/06 . chapter 16
*please* consider continuing this. I just discovered it and am quite hooked
| bubblezbuzz 12/27/05 . chapter 16
please write more i love your story
is there any pairings in here
i have to know
| CatOnAMarathon 12/9/05 . chapter 3
Aw damn. This is the funniest story ever.
| Ellewyn 11/10/05 . chapter 11
I would love for this story to be updated. Remember, I've been poking you for well over 3 years. I know there might not be any hope of this updating...but please. Give it a chance.