 Furius 5/16/02 . chapter 1interesting, would have to say that it is strange that Elrond did not think about his brother while on the road of memory |
 kaput 4/29/02 . chapter 1*blinks* Wow. Wow. That was... wow. Okay *snaps out of it* That was totaly awesome. The imagry was wonderful. And lok at me, I can't even spell straight. Cool! Again, awesome. |
 shinelrond 4/23/02 . chapter 1*does a little dance* yay! Not only did I like the story, I agree with you, it's gotten so that there's so many slash fics out there where the guys go for a romp in the hay and that's it(not that I like slash, I just know there's way to much out there) It's nice to see a fic about a MARRIED couple actually making love and not just getting it on(and it was beautifully written if I do say so myself:) |
 The Potions Mistress 4/23/02 . chapter 1Wow. This is so beautiful. It was very erotic without being explicit, sexual without being pornographic. I really liked this fic. Well, I suppose it helps when you have a monster crush on Elrond, hehe. You are a very good writer. Your imagery in astounding. Hope to read some more of your work.
*TPM* |
 EvilStorm 3/29/02 . chapter 1bloody hell...*speechless* well, you sure got me thinking about passion all right. and if you don't write any more fics with elrond and celebrian, i'll kill you. Don |
 Nessamelda 3/28/02 . chapter 1amazing and very beautifully written |
 anna 3/27/02 . chapter 1 one word: wow! that was beautiful - and passionate! makes me even sadder to think about what happened to celebrian... |
 Sorne What fool gave me an internet connection at work 3/27/02 . chapter 1 This is a total work of art. Wonderfully, and beautifully written. Bringing out so well the double-edged sword that passion is - a recurring theme in Tolkien - as you show with reference to the Silmarils and Ring. But not only that - it's also a hauntingly touching love-scene, a heart stopping peek inside Elrond's heart and mind. Bravo! |
 Woman of the Dunedain 3/26/02 . chapter 1very intense, but well-written |
 Nemis 3/26/02 . chapter 1It appears *you* are now in danger of beheading, unless you promise not to say things like '...unlikely there will ever be another such fic...' ever again...
Because, you see, you *have* to continue... For my sake... |
 Deborah Judge 3/25/02 . chapter 1Well if you don't write anything else like this all I can say is it's a damn shame. This is BRILLIANT! This really goes to the depths of Elrond's soul as I understand him. Beyond that, it is a true presentation of the complexities of desire. You have created something that is totally canon and totally original. I am in awe. Stories like this make worthwhile. |
 me 3/25/02 . chapter 1 beutiful |