Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: Misc. Ideas - Page 3 of 3
Aj 3/27/02 . chapter 5
I enjoyed Nexus, Dark Knight, and the WOT fic.

I especially liked Wot and Dark knight.
Philodox 3/27/02 . chapter 1
My votes:

Dark Knight e WOT
Dragonsey 3/27/02 . chapter 5
Alright, here's my thoughts on the 5 ideas posted so far:

#1 - Nexus - Didn't care for it. While there are a few things about it I didn't like, the worst was that after finishing it I was left with the feeling of "So what?". I can't see where you intend take this story. Any direction I can think of would really require an extensive rewrite of this chapter.

My opinion might change if you add to it enough that I can see where you're going with it, but with just what's written so far, I'll pass.

#2 - Transmetal - Didn't care for this one either, but this may be more a reflection of my tastes than any fault of the story. I rarely like stories where Ranma has a curse that changes him into something not human (or near-human).

#3 - Dark Knight - This one has possibilities. It's a bit dark for my tastes, but a good follow through could make this an interesting story.

#4 - WoT - By far my favorite of the five. This one has definite potential. I would enjoy seeing this one expanded to a full length story.

#5 - Blackadder - Enjoyed it as is (as a one-shot spamfic), but I don't know if it would hold up as an extended fic.
Quamzin Kravshera 3/27/02 . chapter 4
now this one, WOT-Gaiden has possibilities! Please add more, but don't forget your other fics! _
34 found: « Prev Page 1 .. 3
Return to Top