i honestly loved this! i really hope you get a chance to keep going! you should check out my story, It don't mean a thing!

I like it! You really should update!

I would love to read more. Hope you update sometime soon)

I just love their brickering, it's always golden. I like your style, the story flows easily and fun to read. update soon.

I love how different your story line is to the other stories ive read... you never know whats gonna happen... please keep writing i love them...xx

Oh, Puck. You're about to find out just how WRONG you are.
Thanks for this! Update soon.

I love When Harry Met Sally and I was a bit wary at first since most fanfiction that is based on a movie tend to be exactly the same, even their characterization. I look forward to reading more!

love it! great follow up. Keep up the good work!

I like it so far. CAn't wait for more. Puck should be a cop tha tbe a twist since he was such a badboy no whis th elaw that enforces badboys. LOL. Bye:)

Loved it can,t wait for more

U must break up Quick, ASAP!)

...this is amazing. It's a combination of two of my favoritest things ever"When Harry Met Sally" and Puckleberry. Please tell me updates are frequent, because I just might cry if I have to wait too long for a new chapter.

i love this, but the idea of puck marrying quinn not so much. i hope he ditches her and puck and rachel get together. update soon please.

please continue! this is so good i'm so excited to see more!

your characterization of puck and rachel are flawless! can't wait to see more