Great story. I was just watching the movies because of Halloween. Hope you update soon.
:)

"Love is worth forgiving for, now I realize. Everything worth living for is there in his eyes."

ohhhhh please please update! this is the first kal and marnie story i have seen so far... and i really want to see them be a couple!

lol i am late but: I LIKE THIS.

AWESOME! PLEASE UPDATE!

You have got to update this... Please Please Please :(

LOVE THIS SO FAR! HOPING TO READ MORE OF IT LATER! :)

Please continue writing!

This is really good. I can't wait to read more.

Wow this is the only fic. about Marnie and Kal. Well anyway, please continue with the story.

Rider

you should continue like really soon because this story is awesome so far! soo will kal and marnie be a couple? because i always thought they were adorable together, i was just so hoping that he would turn good for her.. too bad he didnt.. but it was still good. then i started liking the ethan/marnie pairing. but i still love kal and marnie the best!

I LOVE it

cool i've been hoping someone would write a story were kal returned

Wow randomly felt like reading a Halloweentown fanfic being so close to the Holiday and find out you are the only story with Kal and Marnie. Guess I'm not the only one who found interest in them being together. Great job on getting into the mindset of the characters and I hope romance doesn't bloom to quick in them. I only wish others will repeat my actions and I hope we'll get an update soon with all this Halloween spirit.

mindless words

I am thanking you for this story, because in the second movie they said he'd come back and he never did. So thank you very much for making this story, it's very good so far.

love it! i think should contiune this story! i would like to know what happens next!