Share/Save/Bookmark
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search Login Register Extras
Reviews For: With this Ring

Christine Ruud
2007-06-22
ch 1,
abuseAw...sweet.
'loha
2006-12-13
ch 1,
abuseIs this a PiperCole fic?Unrequited love? Sounds like it. Good all the same
Badgirl21
2004-05-28
ch 1,
abuseI liked that Piper was accepting Cole into the family. I also liked that Phoebe and Cole are in love and stuff.
Barb6
2002-08-30
ch 1,
abuseI wonder if we will ever see Piper and Cole this close again? Excellent story - I hope we get to see a good wedding soon.
Ivy3
2002-05-05
ch 1,
abuseNice, I like it
Ivy
margaritanightly
2002-04-14
ch 1,
abuseLike a gem that sparkles in a desert mine field. Hope you keep writing. :)
Cindy
2002-04-11
ch 1, anon.
abuseThis was a very enjoyable story. It's fun when writers take a scene and expand it beyond the original story line. The banter between Cole, Phoebe and Piper was very true to the spirit of the characters. Thank you.
Trunks Ichijouji
2002-04-11
ch 1,
abuseThat was good. If they were to have started the episode earlier, your story would've been a great beginning.
Barb
2002-04-11
ch 1, anon.
abuseIt is so great to read a good chapter about Phoebe and Cole! Thank you for a welcome diversion from the show's current story line. I'm glad you filled in the pieces with Piper giving Cole Grams's ring.
Neptune
2002-04-10
ch 1, anon.
abuseWowwie, that was really good. You captured the characters' dialogue perfectly. I could totally see this happening on an episode of Charmed. And Mrs. D is so cool!

Loved the repair man joke, by the way ;o)

Keep writing great stuff like this.
Maggie
2002-04-10
ch 1, anon.
abuseFantastic. Great use of dialogue and knowledge of the characters. I'd love to read more. Finally a little bonding between the ex-demon and one of the sisters.
Lilian
2002-04-10
ch 1, anon.
abuseWow, Shel, that was beautiful!. You really captured their essence right--- and I liked Mrs. D a lot!. This is just what I needed, with all the mess going on in the show. To be remembered that above all, Phoebe and Cole are a wonderful couple, and that tenderness was always a part of their life, even if now it's pretty much gone. I hope you have more where this one came from!
Amber
2002-04-10
ch 1, anon.
abuseThis is really good! This is exactly how I would've pictured Piper giving Cole the ring.
Cathie
2002-04-10
ch 1, anon.
abuseLoved it!! It was a great story. Sorry to say I never read any of your other stories, but i defintly will now.
Return to Top