Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: Good-bye
never u mind 4/5/08 . chapter 1
sorry but it sucked, u killed akane so weirdly. Man at least if u're gonna kill my favorite character, kill her in a way that shows her strength.
windwhisprer 1/2/06 . chapter 1
I really like this. It's sad. I love it.
DeActivated 1/31/04 . chapter 1
omg. . that is SO sad. a perfect angst fic. excuse me while i get some tissue. .
Pogo 4/14/03 . chapter 1
Wow, you write angst extremely well, and it seems I'm a sucker for a good story regardless of its nature.
fu 10/17/02 . chapter 1
u ass that is dipressing PUT an warning on it I was already having a really bad day!
darkami 10/13/02 . chapter 1
That was so sad. I'm seriously gonna need a tissue here if I intend on reading more. But I know I have to. Your stories are just to good. They're so well written.

Hikari
Hitomi 8/3/02 . chapter 1
this was sad! sniff but you are very good writer sniff good job!

Hitomi
Hitomi 4/17/02 . chapter 1
This was good!

Hitomi
Final-Fan 4/13/02 . chapter 1
I think that the Ranma 1/2 characters are stronger than that.

But I still would have thought that this was a good fic.

EXCEPT FOR THE LAST LINE:

"The rest dropped like flies after that."

That ruined it for me. Dropped like flies. I can't adequately express my displeasure, so just imagine it for yourself.

I doubt you'll overestimate.
lija 4/13/02 . chapter 1
Oh my gosh...that was soooo depressing. *sob* Now gonna have to find a cheerful story to cheer myself up.
may 4/12/02 . chapter 1
This is truly magnificent to efficiently reduce me to a puddle of tears!
Brianna Aisling 4/12/02 . chapter 1
see my review for Creature's Offer

oh, and while i am irritated, i do understand that only a certain type of mindset can appreciate what i was attempting

particularly for C.O.
Makotojs 4/12/02 . chapter 1
hm. we'll gotta agree. Good lotline but seems a bit undeveloped.

Also, the people dropping like flies later on... I'm not so sure that would happen. As for Ukyo, being the next one, I couldn;t see that also. Maybe, if you developed it more then the story would be better explained?

However, I did like this story P

The goodbye part was very beautiful ... )

Anyhow, hope to see a revision or a new story from you soon _
Dunefar 4/12/02 . chapter 1
Hmm...

Well, this is a good attempt, but it lacks any real emotional hitting power. It's too brief, you don't build up any sympathy for the events. It goes from Akane acting a bit funny to everyone killing themselves. Even if Akane did kill herself, I don't see anyone following suit. This idea may not be bad for a longer fic where you can flush out the details, but as a shortfic it falls flat. Oh, and you misspelled Kodachi. It's Kodachi, not Kadachi.
Return to Top