Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Somebody's Angel
Just-Jayme
2003-07-14 . chapter 1
This was excellent! I always wanted the last part of the poem and this was great, more than adequate. Good job.
Sister Moon
2002-04-17 . chapter 1
Wow, I love this. "Broken earthbound mortal." How perfect to think of Logan gazing up above the skyline as Max sits on the Needle remembering his words. It also reminds me of their dance. Thanks.
willow7
2002-04-17 . chapter 1
So this is one the few reviews you'll ever see from me for a poem, because I don't think myself capable of understanding most poems, much less interpreting them . . . but for catherder, I'll try. Okay, so while I was reading this, I went back to the scene in SiL and thought of Max's face as she read, and the wonder in her voice when she asked him if it was about her. It works perfectly, for me -- I mean, I can see her reading what you've written her and having that reaction. The *one* line that that might not apply to is "Our lips meet." Gosh, if he wrote that about her and she read it...well, I just think (1) he probably would have never shown it to her and (2) wouldn't one of them had said something about it?

I am very glad you gave us the rest of the poem. One of those DA mysteries we're left to wonder about. It is really beautiful. And while I'm here, more SiS please! =)
Lelu
2002-04-16 . chapter 1
Great finish!!!
gilenagile
2002-04-15 . chapter 1
Really like the sense of movement and the pace to this poem. Can imagine Logan writing it - he's a romantic at heart whether he likes it or not.
Dancinstar
2002-04-15 . chapter 1
I can't say I'm a great reviewer of poetry, but that piece was beautiful! Very much like something I could picture Logan writing.
a fan
2002-04-14 . chapter 1
I love your imagery, Logan's description of himself as a broken earthbound mortal and the angel whose touch allows him to soar. Just beautiful.
Kasman
2002-04-14 . chapter 1
This is really lovely, catherder. More please. "Dark forever eyes again." Love that image.
Return to Top