God. I love this story. I have lost count how many times that I have reread this story. And it still gives me chills and the warm and fuzzies. I loved how they finally aired out all their issues with the proposal and their reasoning. Like why he proposed and why Rory said no. I loved that Logan was able to still call Rory out and make her admit that her career had a huge part in it. And it makes sense to me that Rory would have said no because she just didn't think he was serious. I do think at many points in relationships she was just looking for a way out without it being the bad guy. And Logan just knows her so well that he pointed it out. I love your Rory and Logan stories and this was just fantastic. So emotional and raw and the smut was great too. I hope you decide to do a follow up to this story. I love a good Rory and Logan romance with hopefully a happy ending. Please think about doing a follow up. Your writing is fantastic

READING this again for the...10th time? Lol This is my fave one-shots of all time. I cried again reading it - the while Logan's admission about not drinking anymore. Kills me every time...

this is a hopeful postseason7 rogan. i just really hate how they (whoever was responsible for that crap they call a season finale) ruined GG for me. come on, rory and logan's relationship spanned 3 seasons, longer than dean and jess and definitely more mature and serious and they end up like that! and to think rory told lorelai that they (logan and luke) could be the ones. sorry for ranting. but i very much enjoyed your story.

Absolutely splendid.

Brilliant writing. I would die a happy person if a Gilmore Girls movie ever was in talks. This storyline would suit perfect! :)

So awesome. I want more tho

This is amazing! I've been distracted by the wonderful world of Trory's lately, but thus just helps me remember why I truly am a Rogan fan... :D

wow simply beautiful

Hey I would like to know if you are planning on doing a sequel to this story like you do for many of your one shots. BTW I love your new Trory one. The whole 'Off the record' series is good. Please keep your great stories coming :)

this was pretty brilliant

i love the emotion in it

a sequel would be much appreciate it

great job

I missed you to, I really loved this. You write the best smut scenes filled with passion and longing. i also wear flip flops on airplanes it does make things earlier. Even though i've read in fics Logan's and Rory's reasons for the proposal drama you made some good original ones that Rory didn't take the proposal seriously and she should have. Every good job and I'll be reading this fic over and over

Awe - I really enjoyed this! It was a great fic!

fyi, im reading this again. its THAT good. ;) tthis time around, i just wanted to let u know that i like ur style of describing each emotion as the characters say their lines. it lets the readers emote the same feelings as the chars go through them. love this version!

Loved this story! You captured their personalities so accurately, subtly writing in each one's quirks-it was perfect. Great work :)

Such a romantic story! I love Logan and Rory together and I would love them even more if you make them parents!

I miss them so much and reading stories keeps them alive. Thanks so much for writing.