Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: A Matter of Honor - Page 1 of 7
Paloma Helena Sangre
2007-07-19 . chapter 5
it's a collection of cliches bundled up in several chapters, but what the heck, i like it anyway (i finished reading all 5 chapters, didn't i?).

one of the reasons i like it is that you didn't waste time writing about the scene post-ultimecia and trying to make sense of everything (which i think can be tedious and takes a lot of ingenuity to write to make things fit). and even though you didn't elaborate, you stayed true to the characters-seifer's remorse about his role in the sorceress war, zell's endearing klutziness (is there such a word?), rinoa's possession of her sorceress powers, etc. other writers seem to have conveniently forgotten that seifer does have some deep issues, which are pretty hard to ignore and cannot be forgotten or changed overnight. yet you have addressed that pretty well:

Rinoa: "That wasn’t me! I was possessed!”
“So was I!” Seifer roared back.

that btw is my favorite line in the story.

anyway, good work. thank you for sharing this fic.

now if you don't mind, i'm gonna read your other fics now :D
RainbowKiss
2007-05-22 . chapter 5
a truly splendid story! the computer bugs finally allowed me to get through the final stretch of this fic. this is highly enjoyable. you really have some talent. you did well on your choice of words... goes straight to my fave stories list. keep rockin'!
RainbowKiss
2007-05-21 . chapter 1
what happened to the 5th chapter?? darn! i thought this was completed already!

This fic is a real beauty, by the way, i can't wait to read the conclusion. was that just my computer?? i can't seem to load the page correctly. uh, can you send me a copy of the final chap?? i'm so excited and curious. you're style is very original, raw and poetic. keep writing!! sorry, i can't review on chappie 5.
daggertrepe
2006-07-10 . chapter 5
Cutest story I've ever read! GREAT job! :)
Chloe Corrona
2005-03-26 . chapter 5
Haha! I loved that last line there. This story was very well done. I loved the antics of Quistis' friends to cheer her up, and most of all, I liked the ending. It was very sweet, and made me feel all warm and fuzzy inside. :)

Keep writing!
Modus unoperati
2004-12-07 . chapter 5
Yowtch, swear I musta been half-asleep just now not to see that there were 5 chaps. But good job! Love it. Seifer proposed! Woohoo!
modus unoperati
2004-12-07 . chapter 1
Keep going. It's good. Make Seifer propose to Quisty amidst a setting sun...sorryd:rattling, but I do hope that they get married eventually.
sisterhood of lycanthropy
2004-12-03 . chapter 4
actually, this should be from chapter 5, but my computer is having a bad day...week...
anyways, you really should write the next chapter if there is one, my computer took so darnded long to load each chapter and chapter five stopped abruptly part-way through...
QuistisTrepe-SeiferAlmasy
2004-10-24 . chapter 5
aw! please continue it!! i mean, write something after the wedding! hehe i'd really want to see how they are after getting married... great work!
Verdanii
2004-09-30 . chapter 5
Just magnificent.
Verdanii
2004-09-30 . chapter 4
Lovely chapter.
Verdanii
2004-09-30 . chapter 3
What a fookin fantastic story.
Verdanii
2004-09-30 . chapter 2
Wonderfull chapter man.
Verdanii
2004-09-30 . chapter 1
Fookin great start
Draic
2004-02-29 . chapter 5
Lol. Oh, so you hate it, do you? Ha! I admit it's a far cry from Rain of Roses, but it's really not that bad… for a Seiftis. (shudder) Okay, so the couple has it's charm, but honestly, how many times can you recycle the same idea? Oh, sorry about that ranting. (Don't like Seiftises).
I think for one thing that the melodrama of it all sort of took over. Quistis loves Seifer, Seifer loves Quistis, Seifer misunderstands and leaves Quistis, Quistis cries, Seifer comes to apologise and thinks Quistis is with Irvine… and then finds out she (obviously) isn't. Quistis thinks Seifer is with Rinoa. Seifer thinks Quistis is with Squall. And then they get married. It was amusing at times, but still… it's an unbelievable soapie.
I liked how the main characters got their little cameos (except for Irvine) where they got to open up a bit or assist either Quistis or Seifer. And your little explanation of Seifer made me sit up and take interest - possessed, eh? Hmm. But in the end, it was all a bit too cliched for my tastes.
Wishing you Motivation, Inspiration, and Luck!
~ Draic
Return to Top