I love this AU just as much as I love the original story...such a great job! :)

I like this better just because it's happier and I like reading happy :-)

i loved this

i really enjoyed ur au of a au both stories are great on a i cant wait for an update on the other third time around

mel

Absolutely LOVED this :) Marine Puck, I'd love to see that. I really liked the Quinn & Judy friendships, how Mama P was there for her and just everything! Amazing.

this was very sweet and finn was never heard of again?

Love this so much! I'm so glad that Puckleberry has a happy ending in this one, too. I love Third Time Around-please update that story when you can. Thanks!

It was so interesting to see what could have been and the reactions of all involved. I really liked that more than anything Rachel just wanted the support of her best friend when it became clear that Finn was not going to step up. And as much as Finn was acting like a spoilt brat about Rachel being pregnant I liked that she didn't want to force his hand and get married just because she was pregnant, and that no matter what did happen with Noah,she wasn't going to deny Finn his rights.

I loved that Mama P. was such a good influence and help to Rachel,offering her a roof over her head and much needed advice without ever pushing her own agenda. It was also great to see that Carole didn't take Finn's side in the matter,that she wanted to be a grandmother even when her son was not prepared to be a father.

The relationship between Rachel and Noah was so well written, you really showed their true feelings for one another and how Noah's attempts to help Rachel's dreams come true led to this potentially heartbreaking life changing event. However its clear to see that his decision to marry her, to raise another man's child is due to love and not guilt or responsibility. Rachel for her part shows that just because your childhood dreams don't come true,it doesn't mean your life is any less happy.

My favourite part about this AU you have created,and that you show in both versions of the story,is that a true family does not have to be made up of people who are related by Rachel's dads are quick to abandon their daughter in her time of need,instead the family that surround her and support her have no blood connection but their bonds go much deeper and I love how you show this.

I really liked this version of your story. I don't know why but it's so believable that Finn reacted that way. I know that he's not a bad guy, he's just so self centered and whatever. And Puck just accepting everything and being beside Rachel without any doubt warms my heart every time 'cause I see him exactly like that.

This was awesome.

Loved this! Soooo glad that these two got together in the end:) Loved all the support she had from her friends, especially Noah's mom...& Quinn...& Quinn's mom...& Carole...LOL...really nice:) Thanks for posting...