Erica Headcannon accepted. lol

I enjoyed this very much; I'm a big fan of Catherine! Since the fandom isn't too big, I openly gush about game so people will at least look it up...

Anyway, I though that the characterization was great-Johnny really comes off just like he does in the game: a cool, mature guy (he's my favorite ). Honestly, I had never considered a TobyxJohnny pairing, but you've helped warm me up to it a bit more and now I'm wondering why I didn't think of it. Thanks for writing it! (_)b *thumbs up*

Pfff- don't worry, I'm sure Catherine's fan-base will rise soon enough. There's a potential writer in me.

I love your writing style. They're so in-character, its very fitting. Though I understand how Toby was kinda "eh?" with Erica at the end of the game (it was hilarious), I really like the way you went with it.

This was nicely written (I did always wanna see more insight to what would be going through Toby's mind when he found out), its a shame its a one-shot but that's just because I want more. And yeah its kind of surprising how little fanfiction Catherine has.