Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: The Promise
Elessar King 11/21/02 . chapter 1
that is very cute. hobbits are great! keep writting!
ShireElf 11/15/02 . chapter 1
Beautiful. Absolutely beautiful.
Bluetiful 10/18/02 . chapter 1
Oh that was just... so sweet...

That part in the movie was the second time I cried watching the blasted thing. (The first time being when Gandalf fell)

Oh man, I think this is the best LoTR poem I've ever read ;) Good job!
Forget Yesterday 5/1/02 . chapter 1
EEEE! SO CUTE! I LOVE SAM! Sorry. But he's great.
FurryFeet 5/1/02 . chapter 1
hey, FurryFeet here, yeah, spelling has always been a brick wall for me, I'll use spell checker next time!:)
GreyLadyBast 4/29/02 . chapter 1
Oh, very good! Nice rhyme, nice metre, captures Sam's emotions very well.
Phantom X4 4/29/02 . chapter 1
Awwwe! I love this! It's so sweet and really pretty. Only one critique and it's a technical thing. It's spelled "Following" not "Fallowing", but other than that, I loved it. Absolutely adorable. Keep it up!
Geheimnis 4/28/02 . chapter 1
:) very warm and ... well ... sam-like
Return to Top