|Reviews for What the Sergeant Saw: The St Oswald's Murders|
| Unknown 1/7/13 . chapter 1
"Lewis took the implied criticism quietly. There wasn't any use in defending himself or in trying to keep up. He was a plodder, capable but slow. He wasn't clever or brilliant like Morse nor well educated like Max and the others. He'd made it through school, but it had been a struggle. Bookwork and memorization had not come easily for him;" Really? A lot of people (including Colin Dexter, of course) seem to picture Lewis like that, but - judging from the TV series - somehow I don't believe he was that humble or thought so little of himself. I always had the impression that his infinite patience with Morse's rudeness nad harshness came from his mental and emotional strength, that he simply shrugged it off and let it pass because he had the wonderful ability to accept people for what they were.
| Autohumans 11/8/12 . chapter 5
"Your all I need lass, don't ever lrave me." That sentence really tears me up. I have more respect for Mrs Lewis than ever before.
| noenigma 7/16/12 . chapter 10
These stories aren't so much solving the crime(s) as retelling the story (or bits of it) through the eyes of Sgt. Lewis; the idea being that the reader will already be familiar with the episode. In this case, the man who was supposed to be the first victim was slowly picking off all the others involved in that original murder.
| Guest 7/15/12 . chapter 10
Ok, but who killed everyone else and why? Especially the young boy?
| ailsa craig 12/5/11 . chapter 10
What can I say that has not been said already...that was absolutely marvelous. If you struggled with it as a writer it was certainly worth it for the reader.
When I watch old episodes of Morse I will certainly look at Lewis in a new light! That thought provoking Chapter 10 has certainly taken my blinkers off!
keep writing, please.
| ailsa craig 12/5/11 . chapter 5
I think this could be a tear jerker...oh dear.
| ailsa craig 12/5/11 . chapter 4
This is great and as usual your writing is exceptional. Enjoying this much more than the episode, so far.
Just love that young Robbie!
| WhyAye 12/3/11 . chapter 10
*standing ovation* Bravo! Encore! (I know, I sound like one of those people who badgers you for more don't I? Well, that's because I am.)
| WhyAye 12/3/11 . chapter 7
Awww! Wish this had been in the ep!
| WhyAye 12/3/11 . chapter 6
I love Max in this ep, and you've captured him brilliantly! Well done!
| WhyAye 12/2/11 . chapter 5
Ohhhh! *snif* This is SO touching! Waugh! We knew this is what was going on behind the scenes all this time. How come you got to sneak in there and have a little heart-to-heart with Val when the rest of us weren't looking? I'm seriously crying here!
| WhyAye 12/2/11 . chapter 3
I'm smitten. I love Morse and I love Robbie's thoughts, and your fics combine them. Just had to say that before I get too involved and forget by the end. :D
| princessozmaofoz 12/2/11 . chapter 10
That was absolutely beautiful, albeit very VERY sad. I particularly loved your characterization of Val and that we got to see some of Sgt. Lewis's realistic ( if painful) " human side." Very well-written. I almost cried at parts. Thanks for sharing.
| prosfan 12/2/11 . chapter 10
I really, really enjoyed that. I've enjoyed all the "What the sergeant saw" things you've done, both from Sergeant Robbie and Sergeant Hathaway's POV.
It's always irked me that, while we see Hathaway's suffering(even it it manifests itself in him resolutely protesting that he's fine), we don't see Sergeant Lewis'. The man goes through a lot in his young years and it doesn't get acknowledged, like you 've captured this amazingly well.
This story however is brilliant. It shows perfectly the Robbie that we all know is there, but never really see. The young man in a job that demands too much of him.
And congratulations, you've just made Val's death even more painful. :P Now who had he got to pick him up?
Sorry for that review being so long.
| princessozmaofoz 12/2/11 . chapter 1
That is really, REALLY well-written so far. I especially loved Lewis's conversation with Val at the end of the chapter and his decision to get his suit cleaned when he visits particularly messy crime scenes ( even when the suit in question hasn't been physically besmirched.) It just seemed very in-character.
Unfortunately, all I can read for right now is the first chapter. Shame as I would really like to finish it. :'(
Ah well, something to look forward to later on, I suppose. In any case, well done :)