Not only have they lost Bobby, they're gonna have to be Bobby to god knows who all.

OMG that was sad. I still won't use the words "dead' and the name "Bobby" in the same sentence. I feel like if I do that it will make it so. As long as I'm in my land of denial then I'm fine. Right after Sammy Bobby and Dean tied for my fvaorite character. Not having Bobby has left this huge hole in my heart while I'm watching the show. I keep thinking the boys would be doing so much better if Bobby was there. Sam wouldn't be ready to be checked into a mental hospital if Bobby were there. Even if he was Bobby would help Dean get him out of this. It's just not fair. Excellent job! Total tear jerker. One little thing though. Bobby came on the last couple episodes in the first season not the second. Remember? Meg was exorcised and died at Bobby's house.

Great ep indeed! Loved it all!

Your story added a lot of color to it.

I liked this line best: they both just sat there, not lost in a cause, or even a haze - just lost.

Thank you much for sharing,

Karen

You're just so good with the brothers' relationship.

I loved that you quoted Sam's words from AHBL part2:- "You're my brother; there's nothing I wouldn't do for you." because that scene has always remained with me; Dean's almost surprised, but so happy that Sam would feel that way about him too.

Great story, thanks:-)

Loved this. Such a sad episode but I loved the ending. So much was said without words between the two. I wish Dean had let Sam open up to him. But it's the Winchesters. I still can't believe Bobby is gone. Thanks so much.

Good story. And I agree: nooooo, Bobby!

loved this fic!

I love this story. But I still haven't stopped saying Nooooo Bobby. Can't believe he's gone.

Beautiful.

Lovely tribute )

Oh girl, you definitely did it justice! Such a great and totally sad episode, Dean trying to smile and blinking back his tears in the end just broke my heart. I love the boys interaction here, very emotional, brought tears into my eyes too. Just a perfect tag, thanks!

So let me say this first; the episode made me cry, not just the One Perfect Tear like Jensen puts it, but a whole damn flood.. I was sortve expecting Bobby to fight back, and if not I was expecting the boys to deal. But the lost way they sat through the whole week. Oh God, that made me tear up.

And after the shock wore off..the ending made it start all over again. Man...the way Dean tries to smile through his tears, blinking them back over and over. It effing hurt so much to see him like that...

I loved how you extended the ending, its like the boys do not have to say anything. And yes, they only have each other left..beautiful, painful episode. And you made it epic.. Thank you!

So let me say this first; the episode made me cry, not just the One Perfect Tear like Jensen puts it, but a whole damn flood.. I was sortve expecting Bobby to fight back, and if not I was expecting the boys to deal. But the lost way they sat through the whole week. Oh God, that made me tear up.

And after the shock wore off..the ending made it start all over again. Man...the way Dean tries to smile through his tears, blinking them back over and over. It effing hurt so much to see him like that...

I loved how you extended the ending, its like the boys do not have to say anything. And yes, they only have each other left..beautiful, painful episode. And you made it epic.. Thank you!

U thought he was gonna jump out... Huh

I thought he was gonna try and sleep-and I say try because how the heck does he fit In the car?

It's funny I cried at the end with a stupid smile on my face-I don't even understand it

And Ioved this story of yours u did it justice!

Your story reflects what I saw in Dean's face at the end of the episode. The trying to smile, but not being able to hold it, trying to hold himself together and failing. I could see him trying to follow Frank's advice, but it wasn't easy. I didn't know what Sam was doing either, when he shifted towards the door. I realized quickly though, that Sam was just trying to get comfortable in a car that was too small, and wasn't 'home'. He didn't know what to say to Dean, he didn't have the strength, or the mental capacity to have a long talk with Dean, so he just showed his support, then tried to ignore everything, and just shut everything out. I feel so bad for the boys. How much more can they take?

I love your little insights to the characters. You do such a great job with them. :) Those lyrics sure fit Sam and DEan, don't they?