Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: When All Other Lights Have Gone Out - Page 1 of 3
Doubleblade Miriko
2009-07-15 . chapter 2
I'm crying, I'm realy crying. And I'm crying, because you haven't written more of this! You promised torture and you haven't written torture! Yes, I now, sadistic and twisted person, but I wanna read more of this! Gather our strenght and keep writing this, because I love this, and I wanna see what kind of methods they are using in torture in Mordor.
Noldo wise
2006-06-24 . chapter 2
I rilly like where your story is going plese write more!
sam/'s girl
2004-11-13 . chapter 2
Told ya I'd review. I liked that one better. But I have one question...WHERE IS MY SAM!
I love sam (look at my pen name ) so please don't kill 'em. If you do, I will kill you! Muhahahaha *cough* still not good at that stuipd laugh.

P.S. You know I'm kidding about that, right? My sister ( she is also using this pen name, so if you get a bad remark on one of your storys, she did it! I'm the good sister!) says I'm not allowed to kill. Dang it for younger sisters
I will write again! Muaha *cough* hahah *cough* oh! forget it.
sam/'s girl
2004-11-13 . chapter 1
well...that was...what is the word I'm looking for...differnt. I don't know how you thought that up but that was pretty good. I liked it. I'm going to read the next chapter and I will reveiw! Muhahahahaha *cough* not good at that laugh
Wolfram-and-Hart-Sauron
2004-10-18 . chapter 2
Love it!
Troll bogeys.
2004-05-17 . chapter 2
this is the best lord of the rings fanfic I've ever read!It's almost as good as the work of Tolkien himself.I am not in any way exaggurating
balrogthane
2004-05-07 . chapter 2
WOW. Very well-written, love (or am terrified of) the style and the idea. Keep it up!
(see, I'm nice! [nicer, anyway...])
-(- - -
Cazrolime
2004-03-08 . chapter 1
*screams and hides behind chair*
This is SCARY.
Danny Barefoot
2003-12-31 . chapter 2
Very good, suspense, decription, and original
Skull Bearer
2003-11-05 . chapter 2
*Falls over* IT'S ALIVE!

This was entering the competition of the longest lag in updating. It's won.
Congats but it was no appeasement for we rabid fans who have been waiting a year and a half to see Middle-Earth get squished.

*Grabs Orc spear* Update or I'll Shish Kebab you!

Alright, I think it's time for me to calm down slightly. I rarely loose control like this so that's another first.

I'm not sure if I should put this on my favourites list, if it's going to take you another two years to update, no thanks. This was on my favourite stories once, but I lost hope after a year and removed it.

So this review will be more than my deranged raving, I'll say what I thought:

Very, very good.

Honestly.

I'll not say it was worth the wait, because the wait was rediculous as you well know. But it was still brilliant and very spooky.

I love the Ringwraiths and Sauron, they are a very cool creation and you do them justice.

BTW, I was Sauron's Blood who reviewed ages ago, once upon a time when I didn't have a place here.
Now I'm a Skull Bearer, with claws. And fangs. And black magic.

Get my drift? UPDATE.
Rebecca Starflower
2003-10-26 . chapter 2
why oh why did it end there! the description of sauron's return to body was great. i'm worried it will take you a year to update this again, so i'll ask nicely for it to be updated soon but i don't want to rush you...
Rebecca Starflower
2003-10-26 . chapter 1
...*speechless*

...

...wow. very strong, very strong. look, you've broken my brain! um..wow.i seriously can't find proper words. this is incredible, its dark and powerful...wow.
yahiko
2003-10-16 . chapter 2
THAT WASNT NICE YOU SHOULD KNOW BETTER AS A WRITTER THAN TO LEAVE US OFF LIKE THAT. I SWEAR YOUR WORKIN FOR THE DARK LORD HIMSELF! anyway good story realy captivating keep going!! ^ ^
Mireiswen
2003-10-12 . chapter 2
wowza. poor frodo, instead of just a finger, his whole hand was chopped off!! you said that you wanted 'constructive criticizm' but I really think that you are quite possibly one of the best authors on FF.net... the only thing is that I think you should make your chapters just a tad longer, but not too much or it becomes a little tiresome. You know, its kind of like, "man! i love this story but it's so much information at once!" anywho, love it. oh and please don't kill frodo, I don't enjoy reading stories that do that...
ME
2003-10-11 . chapter 2
goodness! continue soon! and hey, u'll probably get more readers if we don't have to wait a YEAR for each update *hint hint* but very very good, one of the best i've read, pleaz PLEAZ oh PLEAZ continue soon!
Return to Top