Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: Prophecy Lost - Page 4 of 13
PeaceGuardian 1/17/08 . chapter 32
I swear, if you don't finish this story I don't know what to say! It's so good! I hope Pratt will turn to the light and stuff cuz of Brummel and stuff, but I don't know, you're a crazy good writer at building suspence though. and is Lacian a jedi? Well...this story is friggin awesome and you have to update sooN! SOON! UPDATE KEEP WRITING UNTIL YOU FINISH IT!
PeaceGuardian 1/17/08 . chapter 30
Reallyt good, I'm sad about all the people dead though. I liked Goren and Crinnin. Good job! I shake when I read, so anxious and exciting.
i luv ewansmile 12/31/07 . chapter 32
Aww. I just love you story!

That last bit with Obi-wan and the young boy was "aww" worthy and heart-breaking at the same time. Gosh.

I have entertained myself for a few hours with this fantastic story. I don't know how I have not stumbled upon it sooner. But I am very glad that I did.

I love the Obidala. But poor Anakin, and all the other Jedi.

You write action, and romance extremely well. I'm very intrigued to find out how this battle will end.

Please update as soon as you can. I will be anxiously awaiting! :)
AMBERLEAH 12/27/07 . chapter 32
I'm so worried about Brummel...you're doing a great job writing that.

And at the end Obi-wan and the boy. It was so emotional. I love it when obi-wan told the boy that he would get rid of the soldiers, "all of them." it was precious. It was the right amount of emotion for that time. You're fantastic at giving us a break after such emotional surges and then just give us a little bit of humor in there. and seriousness. i could picture how grave obi-wan's voice was when he said the line.

anyhow, it was a great chapter and i'm looking forward to the next.
AMBERLEAH 12/10/07 . chapter 30
I was so thankful that Obiwan and Padme were able to get a moment to catch their breaths. I believe they both needed it, to be able to continue their jounrey.

I feel so awful for Brummel. I can understand his hate, but I also know that it's very dangerous...it'll break my heart if he falls to the dark side...but well if it's part of the story, i'll completely understand.

It was a great chapter. It really let me as the reader catch my breath for a moment. And that was good. But it also wasn't to much of a breather! If that makes any sense.

I look forward to the next chapter. Take care!
seren23 12/9/07 . chapter 30
An absolutely beautiful chapter. I am so scared for Brummel and so happy Padme and ObiWan are reunited. Your action scenes are the most fluid I've read. How you've managed to capture lightsaber fights is just amazing. Cannot wait for the next chapter. Just fantastic!
AMBERLEAH 12/4/07 . chapter 29
I just have to say i hated that sabe died...i'm guessing brummel will die also and that's just heartbreaking...Not that it didn't belong in the story..it just hurts.

I'm glad that obi-wan and padme have been reunited, but i know something bad is about to happen, so i'm extremely nervous. This story must take up a great deal of time...because you go into such great detail and it's fantastic. thanks for sharing it with me.
AMBERLEAH 12/3/07 . chapter 27
i'm reading through the story and I'm on chapter 27. It's been a gigantic story to get through and it's been difficult to read at times...I'm sure that was the desired effect. It's dark and sad, but it's amazing. I enjoy it so much and I am so glad you are finishing it. i would have hated to read all this and then have no ending. I just want you to know that I think you are very talented and would enjoy reading any story you write. you obviously think through the details and plot lines and it shows. This has just been a joy to read.
Obi-WanTPM 11/27/07 . chapter 1
Geeze...you make my stories look like dirt...this is an awesome story...wow...
Tierney Beckett 11/27/07 . chapter 1
Wow. Just...wow.

I found this story yesterday and just finished reading it. Along with Lionchilde's 'One Path', I've gotta say this is my favorite Obidala story I've ever found.

In particular, I like the character of Brummel Carde. Since he is your OC (unless I'm missing something in the EU), I would like to ask your permission to do something. If you don't mind, I would like to borrow Brummel for my own Obidala fic. I'm afraid it's nowhere near the quality of yours and I'd understand if you refuse. I have a few OC's of my own that I'm rather protective of. But I give you my word to treat the character with the respect he deserves and that you deserve. I wouldn't have him going off the deep end or anything. But I need a few Jedi that have survived the Purge. And, aside from Shaak Ti, Brummel Carde is the first one I've come across that I truly like.

But on to the actual review. Your characterization of Obi-Wan is brilliant. I love the way you write his sense of humor, especially. So dry. Your take on his relationship with Padme and what leads up to the revelation of their feelings towards one another is one I haven't seen before in Obidala stories. Very unique. A little faster than usual, but explained nicely.

I can't wait to see more of this. I'm seeing a darker side of Obi-Wan as he faces Darth Ovid, which is intriguing. Yet he's still the same Obi-Wan in essence. Excellent story! Thanks for posting it and sharing it with us.
Rae 11/26/07 . chapter 12
"I will kiss you again," he said. "In this life or another."

WOW! GOOD STUFF!
PadmeKenobi 11/20/07 . chapter 27
That was so intense. I am so glad you updated, and it was a superb chapter, as usual. I do hope Obi-Wan kills that Sith bastard, so this hell can finally end. Anyway, can't wait till the next chap! :D
seren23 11/20/07 . chapter 27
Ah! Wait! More! Talk about suspense. What a fantastic chapter. Once again, your Obiwan is exactly how I always wanted him to be. And Padme with such a clear, strong, intelligent will, she's what I always thought Leia's mother would be like. Cannot wait for the duel to continue. Really great chapter!
seren23 11/19/07 . chapter 26
Oh wow! I'm very glad you're continuing this story. I was so impressed with it when I read it a while back. I love what you do with Obi-Wan. The details of the battles are just spot on and amazing. Please do continue!
Kenobifan 11/17/06 . chapter 13
"If I live through this, I will never complain about ..." I noticed you put this line in the last chapter, about Anakin wouldn't complain about Obi-Wan,...and now Obi-Wan is saying the same about Anakin... LOL..

Your definition of love was perfect.. :)
181 found: « Prev Page 1 .. 2 3 4 5 6 7 .. 13 Next »
Return to Top