you said we wouldn't like Rosalie in this chapter,but this just made me like her even more and Harry even less he's so disrespectful his mom just explained what happened and he still is being a brat calling people out of their names. rose had every right to say what she had to say because it was her house that she was being disrespected in .and the fact know one stood up for her even though Harry was being so mean,they still took his side .

sorry I get really into stories like this its a great story so please continue I'm loving the drama and I love it when I react like that to a story because it shows how much I like it .PLEASE CONTINUE

this is interesting, lets see how it goes..

A quand la suite ?

Well, of course, Harry has a right to be angry. Id never meet the woman if she is my mom.

First, she wasn't obliviated. Second, she's a mother. That alone would have been enough to abandon Dumbledore's insensitive plan. Is her life more precious than Harry? Harry lives a horrible life with the Dursleys and almost died every year at school in the wizarding world! If we follow canon, harry died again as he is the last horcrux and Lily is having a comfortable life elsewhere? Snape, horrible as he is, did more to Harry than she did considering she's the mother. Besides, im sure she knows about the prophesy. That's the reason she and James and little Harry has been hiding. SO she knows how dangerous Harry's life is. Why didn't she do anything? Granting that she cant care about Harry personally, she should have visited, communicated. She could have threatened the Dursleys. She have Cullen's money and she could have hired people to look in on Harry daily to avoid Dursley's abuse. And why isnt she aware what happened in the wizarding world? Isnt it too much to subscribe to Daily Prophet?

And she knows Sirius is not the secret keeper? DId she let a friend of James, her husband, suffer needlessly for 12 years in Azkaban? She could have told Dumbledore the change of secret keepers? Of Dumbledore didnt tell her the situation, Alice could tell her. After all, Alice saw Harry even without knowing him personally so you cant say Alice cant see Sirius. And how about Moony? She knows the bigoted views of the wizarding world about werewolf...why not send little money anonymously to make his life better? She has a lot to answer for.

No, i still dislike lily immensly. I see why harry would go to see her but shed deserve it if he just turned around and left. Shes been so selfish all this time.

So lily abandoned her son. I hope harry wont go to see him. Id understand if albus had obliviated her but now she's just a coward and very lousy mother.

Well I am a bit surprised at how calm Harry has been so far considering everything. I am a bit surprised that harry didn't attack Rose with his magic when she let into him in chapter four. I do hope that someone gets really ticked off at the dear dead headmaster, I am a little sad that Harry hadn't yelled at his portrait as that man defiantly deserved it and more. My only note on the writing that I have is that sometimes you change from writing "looks to looked" that's it but other then that everything is wonderful. I look forward to the next installment to this wonderful story whenever both real life and the muse for this story allow.

Wow. I have'nt read any angst fics in a while. This fic is amazing. I can feel the emotions and i can totally understand how harry is so hostile towards the cullens and lily but i think you should tone it down a bit because i think, its only what i think ok, that the situations are moving a bit to fast. I also would like to point out that maybe you should make a chapter in edwards pov because it might be interesting in another pov. Thanks for creating this story and i hope to hear more from you .

Interesting story! Look forward to the next update.

supert history

I enjoyed this... made me cry to that such a thing was possible

I love ur story . I hope u update soon .

Loving it so far cant wait for more

ummmmm...could you update please? really good, only one real plot hole i could find, how was lilly changed if she was alreasy dead? i would clariffy that, say that she was near dead. but otherwise real good, would like more please.

Lovely story! I like it thus far and am looking forward to more. Thanks for sharing!