Reviews for The Cocoon Gentlemen's Society
FeatherBerry 9/25/12 . chapter 2
Why not a threesome? Haha, don't mind me, I just love my love triangles. This is a really unique story I've come across here! Strangely, I think they're quite in character! Noctis, according to all the Versus news so far, is supposed to be a bit shy but everyone else writes him as cold and dead sexy. I think I prefer your cute Noctis a bit more!

Well done on the story so far! Eagerly awaiting for more updates.
fhobos 8/23/12 . chapter 2
This is quite interesting! (And not written in such a way that would compel me to swear off all fanfiction forever, thank you!)

I was curious how you'd pull an Ouran-esque twist to this AU and I have to say - it WORKED. Noctis and Lightning's respective reasons for joining the host club makes sense, according to the characters you've drawn up. I really like how you've characterized Noctis here - it's a refreshing departure from the usual, and might actually fit what his actual personality is like in the yet-to-be-released-game. You've taken what we DO know - that he's handsome, and projects a cool demeanor around people because he's actually shy (except around his friends). Lightning in your story is less grumpy/cold - she does loosen up in the second game - but I'd imagine her personality would be something like this if the circumstances of her life had been different. And this IS AU so: OOC generally accepted. :)

I vote for Noctis/Lightning! I'm interested in how your versions of them would eventually grow together. Thanks for writing!
MidnightNocturne 8/18/12 . chapter 2
Me gusta
Waiting for the next chapter!
brokenmaelstrom 8/6/12 . chapter 2
Firstly, thanks for writing and sharing )

This is a nice twist on the Host Club story. Poor Light ahaha. I can't wait until Cloud is actually involved in the story. Makes me wonder though, is Serah still Light's sister too? Hmm...

On the topic of pairings, typically Lightning and Noctis would get together... awkward guy in crushing on a sweet gentle girl with another tough-girl trying to help him get together with her and ends up getting confused - sweet girl falls for playboy friend - etcetc. I know everyone will be jumping for the Lightis ship, but I'm curious as to see the Prompto/Lightning ship take off.

The Prompto you've written has an almost relentless/villainous side to him that would make things quite interesting when interacting with Lightning. She sees right through his acts and bullshit and isn't afraid to call him out on it - something he probably isn't too familiar with when dealing with females. While one could argue that being with the current innocent Noctis would help soften up her demeanour, I think that having her and Prompto bicker and argue would be more entertaining.

Prompto obviously cares a lot for Noctis and wants Light to help him, but she's harsh and won't pull the punches, which could potentially get Prompto's protective side acting up, like it did when Light was laughing at Noct in the change room. Threats of rage quitting and more blackmailing will probably ensue. Not to mention, but Prompto would easily be able to get under Light's skin and get her agitated over the littlest things. He is unused to handling women with his true feelings and self, and she can't stand fakers and liars or letting them get close to her. Light would see no reason to give someone the time of day if they themselves weren't going to give something equally honest or real back to her. He can be straight forward or cunning and sly getting behind her barriers, and she probably wouldn't accept anything that wasn't real coming from him.

I suppose you could say that Lightis is like peeling the proverbial bandaid off slowly and gently - it's awkward and still stings no matter how hard you try to be gentle, and Prompto/Lighting (Lighto? Promlight?) is like ripping them off quickly - sudden slap in the face kind of hurt and is in no way slow or gentle.

/ends word vomit

Anyhow, I was going to spew out some more but I figured you had enough of my brain fart to read ahaha.

Happy writing
zeroblade63 7/21/12 . chapter 2
Great story cant wait for the next chapter
marchenne 6/27/12 . chapter 1
I can tell this one gonna be great story. Please update soon and daily! I cannot wait for future chapters!
cemeo 6/20/12 . chapter 2
Ya, I choose Noctis x lightning,because of the awesomeness and they're badass couple.

But at the same times I agree if prompto trying his luck, he's not a gay btw, eventhough at the end of the day, light still end up with Noctis
Guest 6/20/12 . chapter 2
Ya, I choose Noctis x lightning,because of the awesomeness and they're badass couple.

But at the same times I agree if prompto trying his luck, he's not a gay btw, eventhough at the end of the day, light still end up with Noctis
lucky17 6/16/12 . chapter 2
haha i'm not surprise if that boys acting like that, boys will boys by the way, at least we certain now that noct is not a gay and prompto not his lover lol who would let the opportunity like that to fly away. she's beautiful with her creamy porcelain skin so delicious to look at lol. helping their imagination run wild flew through heaven. I same as other's can't believed that your make us choose?... i choose NOCTIS X LIGHTNING... prompto absolutely cute if he got serious woman like claire but unfotunately she's so adorably cute and awesome with Noctis, but i'm not approving prompto with vanille either they just look like big ass double trouble joker and harley quin, i prefer him with some serious girl or oc
lucky17 6/16/12 . chapter 1
At least Noct not really that gay if he still have feelings on certain girl right? he just picky! yes cloud and claire height only differentiate by an inch, so no sweat if light would like to covered for him, besides she's intellegent and smart, nosebleed! goddess in lingerie! lesbian also going to pounce at her haha
hune 6/13/12 . chapter 1
fortunately there're not much different between light and cloud height, there are standing almost the same height side by side thank God!
fahree 6/13/12 . chapter 1
Is that cid raines or else? i like cid raines lol

so lucky Noctis and Prompto lol

Poor lightning rofl
Xaphrael 6/12/12 . chapter 2
Hello first off, this is my first time actually signing up to post a review xD. Great story first off by the way, I haven't watched the series this is similar to but plan to later on sometime. Also I'll give a more detailed review later if I can, but personally I think Noctis x Lightning has better potential than Prompto x Lightning, I personally believe a better story can be made and have much better character development with Lightis.
Graham Aker 6/12/12 . chapter 2
Best way to end a chapter EVER! I vote for LightningxNoctis beacuse like someone(sorry didn't read you name) said in I think a few posts down "Noctis really needs Light" Noctis and Lightning look so damn cute together XD(wow I never used the word cute before :o)! Hope to see you update soon not just for this stroy but all the other stroys to so tell your next upload I have just this one thing to say...good luck...!
FarronCaelum 6/10/12 . chapter 2
of course i will prefer this fanfic. to be LIGHTIS...it will be mooore cute.:"
40 | Page 1 .. Last Next »