|Reviews for Healer or Killer|
| passing thru 7/18/11 . chapter 2
cliffhanger again - please do continue, I've enjoyed it so far.
| rick 12/8/09 . chapter 2
please do finish the story - it's very fine & I am enjoying it a lot. Thank you for writing.
| Please Enter Your Name 12/1/05 . chapter 2
...it's MAGLOR! Hahaha. It has to be... I think. ;;
| Lirenel 4/17/04 . chapter 1
Oh and I wanted to say that I also don't know where Gil-Galad lived in the First Age. Only reference I found was that he was with Cirdan on the Isle of Balar. But somehow, that just doesn't fit right for me, I always picture him on the mainland. So in the story I'm attempting to right about Gil-galad, Elrond, and Elros (which will probably never be as good as yours) I just made up a city by the Bay of Balar. Close enough.
| Lirenel 4/17/04 . chapter 2
Surprisingly I have no clue who he is. Based on blond hair, though, i'd have to say wither Glorfindel or Thranduil/Oropher. Update soon!
| bookworm 2/18/04 . chapter 2
I'm very lazy, so I will write this one review for all of your LotR fics that I have read. I enjoy stories about Gil Galad and Elrond, especially non slash ones depicting Elrond's childhood. Thank you for sharing yours!
-BookWorm's guess: Glorfindel? Damb he's hot. Despite the whole literary character thing. I'm half glad he *wasn't* in the movie, because no one could live up to the image in my head.
| Stacey 11/11/02 . chapter 2
Glorfindel-sama? *squeal* Write more!
| alena 6/14/02 . chapter 2
Very well written: great building of tension.
| iamtheanonymous 6/12/02 . chapter 2
Great story! I like the part where the warrior elf explained the healer thing to Elrond..Elrond seems very vulnerable right here...well can't wait for the next chapter :)
| Random Reviewer 6/10/02 . chapter 2
Ohhhhhhhhhhhh...No, I don't have a clue, but nevermind, I'm sure all will be revealed in the second chapter *hint, hint* PLEASE update, I know you're waiting for some reveiws, but carry on! If everyone expected loads of reviews before posting, then no one would update! (Oops, going a bit hyper there sorry) But seriously, why not do it for the in depth & glowing reviews you DO get, rather than the "I lurve ur story its sooooooooooooooooooooooooooo cool! Update NOW PWEASE?" you don't get?
Aezy, the mailing list girl.
| Ada Kensington 6/9/02 . chapter 2
Could it be Glorfindel?
| jillian baade 6/9/02 . chapter 2
Ok, so who's the mystery elf? Nice start to the story.
| sketch 6/9/02 . chapter 1
O_o sorry,on my other review,i meant "mature" not "nature". -_-*
| sketch 6/9/02 . chapter 2
is the elf Glorfindel? _ just a guess.
i like how you're writing this;elrond is a bit more nature than usual for children,but not too grown up. :)
| Anita H 6/8/02 . chapter 2
Yes yes...I think I know who it is. Juggling with the original timeline isn't so bad in this case :)
I looked up your Gil-galad question btw.
" When Gondolin was lost, Gil-galad received the Kingship of the Noldor; he dwelt with the Exiles of the city at the Mouths of Sirion during the remainder of the First Age." (from the encyclopeia of Arda)
And another thing...this Elrond series is really good! I love reading childhood stories about our favorite characters.