Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: The Chrestomanci Arc
Marie Suzette
2006-09-04 . chapter 2
Although I think the Chrestomanci integration is done very well, the Harry Potter integration is a bit more iffy. The writing style appeals to me (and the beginning, especially, I thought very reminiscient of the Chrestomanci series), and although the Rowena Chant facing down Voldemort was a bit less believale, the Rowena Chant teaching Defense Against the Dark Arts was a great deal moreso. Either way, it all seems a moot point since it's been years since you've updated ...
Cerisa
2004-02-29 . chapter 2
Great story! Please finish it!
A. Nutter
2003-05-31 . chapter 2
Wow, come on, hurry up, update! Damn, this is a good story. It's the first Chrestomanci/Harry Potter fic I've read, and now I know why no one else has done one. It's hard to have elements from both stories, and still make it work. You have made it work.
Keep going, I'll be waiting for your next chapters!
Katarik
2003-05-27 . chapter 2
This is quite an interesting idea. I dopn't believe I've ever seen a Harry Potter/Chrestomanci crossover. Please, continue.
A. Nutter
2003-05-27 . chapter 1
Erm, hi.
I'm kinda confused as to which world they're in.
"America was actually called Atlantis" Well, that's 12A, where Chrestomanci lives.
"In another, there was no magic at all and people didn’t ever grow up to be wizards or witches." That's 12B, where we live, and where Janet (Gwen's double in the first book) comes from, and also where Hogwarts is set. If they have to travel from world to world, maybe you should have made that clearer.
I'm not Flaming, just trying to help, and to figure out which world it actually is.
Beboots
2003-03-26 . chapter 2
May I just say that that story was wonderful?! I loved it! Please, please update soon! (Although I see you haven't updated in a while. . . I'll be checking back every day!) It all fits together really well. ^^
Stormy1x2
2003-02-28 . chapter 2
Awesome! ^^ I loved your GW fics - you can't imagine how thrilled I was to see you branch out into Harry potter.^^ Great work!
Virgo
2002-12-14 . chapter 2
I really like what you've done with the place. ::grins:: Your concepts are quite amusing, and i'd really like to know if Draco is as powerful as his father wanted him to be. And how many lives Rowena has left. And so on and so forth. ::grins:: I suppose she's not Chrestomanci yet... Oh, I can't wait to read more, Write on!
cherrylad
2002-09-03 . chapter 2
alrighty then.
oooh finally discovered another story to have me waiting for the update, v. exciting ;)
Going to be a boring reviewer and not give criticism and suggestions. but, include lots of enthusiasm for the storyline, liking Chant, and finally a realistic mention of something that teenagers talk about all the time, sex. And STD's at that >>applause>>
Malting
2002-08-29 . chapter 2
YAAAAY!!! Cool!! An update... this story, so far, is *fantastic*...
I realised about five seconds after I posted my last review that you had only said maybe to a whole humongous story... ooops.
But, thankfully, you ARE writing a whole story... YAAAAAAY!!!!!
sasori
2002-08-28 . chapter 2
=^^= i like the Chants. i like Draco. thank you for putting them together. *YAY*
cherrylad
2002-08-19 . chapter 1
Tell me more,
tell me more
like does he have a car..

no, no, i mean tell me more of the story ;)
Opal Elf -Nightshade Darkrose
2002-06-13 . chapter 1
wow. Is there going to be any more? (Fin. I got that, but is there a sequal?) This was a extremely wonderful story!
Malting
2002-06-10 . chapter 1
I've never seen anything like this done before... and this is very, very good. I love the Chrestomanci books - I love ALL Diana Wynne Jones's books - I love Harry Potter - this is great! Please please please update this soon, I can't wait to see what's going to happen next.
Return to Top