Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Reviews for: Bird song - Page 1 of 2
Atari Shadowfox
2003-03-31 . chapter 14
WOW! that was a good story. the ending was perfect
At
The Little Mermaid
2003-01-18 . chapter 14
Hmm...very interesting. I liked this story a lot. Though it made me so mad that she didn't stay with Alrovir in the first place.

So, now you can add another person to your list of those who have read your fic.
Starbrat
2002-10-16 . chapter 14
Nice story.
Human Nature
2002-09-07 . chapter 13
It is such a wonderfull story.
I really enjoyed it.
I don't know how to tell you... My thoughts are trying to struggle out but they don't come in words. I'll tell you for sure, they are all good.
gershwin
2002-09-06 . chapter 13
Aw. Wah! Cool endng--and good name for the bird.
Starbrat
2002-09-06 . chapter 12
Well, it seems that that the Elves aren't as isolated as previously thought.
gershwin
2002-09-05 . chapter 12
Thank you! I think Mithrandir entered the scene here...Hmmm...am curious as to how this will end...guess I will just have to wait. Not like I have a choice ;-)
Starbrat
2002-09-03 . chapter 11
Aw, sweet! But I find myself wondering why an elf would quote Celine Dion.
gershwin
2002-09-03 . chapter 11
boy, am I reliable or what? Wah! Poor Alrovir, poor Alex. A bittersweet ending to this chapter. You know, if you're a nice person (and I am sure you are) you could post the next installment on Sept. 5 (my date of arrival on thiis planet--and it has never been the same since--or so I have been told). Again, cool chapter, one of my favorites.
gershwin
2002-09-01 . chapter 10
I thought of changing my sign in name, but nah...boy, when you ended with that 'went on with my life' I could have figuratively strangled you. was relieved to see that was not the ending. Am curious to see what you have up your sleeve.

Your faithful and humble reviewer
gershwin
2002-08-28 . chapter 9
ah...well I was close on the bird song thing--at least I can say I was in the ballpark. But now I am curious about those who would attack the elves...unless they are orcs, of course. please post soon.
gershwin
2002-08-24 . chapter 8
I'm back! fun 2 chapters--and all in one day.
am curious about her comment about 'day of departure' drawing near--- her leaving seemed a bit uncertain at the end of chapter 6 anyway--with Elrond's 'we'll see' being the only comment. Am curious to see if my personal 'bird hypothesis' will be confirmed. will Haldir be entereing the picture [you mentioned him in an earlier chapter]?
I will anxiously await your next posting.
gershwin
2002-08-21 . chapter 6
trusty (but sometimes thick) reviewer strikes yet again. I caught on to the rivendell enclave thing after I posted and re-read the story. (serves me right for reading in the early AM hours. I have a hunch about the birds. But I will try to wait and see if my hunch is correct.

Happy b-day!
Starbrat
2002-08-21 . chapter 6
Happy Birthday!
gershwin
2002-08-20 . chapter 5
Your trusty reviewer strikes again--but I am now confused again--what is the enclave from which few humans have come to and left with their lives?" Sounds sinister to me. Please update soon--I don't know if I can take this ;-) And I am curious because you seem to imply that the birds are more than they appear to be. hmmmm. I'll be pondering this until you post again.
Return to Top