Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Search
Reviews for: Return to Me - Page 1 of 2
Sugargirl002 8/23/09 . chapter 1
You're an amazing writer, you came up with much better dialogue than the pathetic sequel to Gone With The Wind, I really didn't like Alexandra Ripley's writing style.
imelda72 1/30/06 . chapter 1
That was great! Now why couldn't Margaret Mitchell have ended it that way?

OK, maybe her ending is appropriate, but this is the ending we all WANT to see. You recommended someone else's GWTW fic, I think? I will definitely check it out, as this is the first one I've ever read (save 'Scarlett.' *Shudder*).

It seemed to take you a while to get into the right sound-there's no other word-of Scarlett's world; at the beginning it didn't sound very much like her words. But once you got to

"I can’t bring myself to believe that," he announced. "Scarlett Butler, you wouldn’t die for anyone or anything in the world."

"But I would!" she argued passionately. "I would, Rhett, I would!"

I was so impressed; those lines really hit the nail on the head with their voices.

And I agree. Rhett COULDN'T stop loving Scarlett. It's just not possible.
Abigail-Nicole 1/30/04 . chapter 1
Odd. Very odd. It was so...so canon, if that makes sense. (Also, an FYI: to canonize someone means to make them a saint. Odd, no?)
I like GWTW and have written some stuff in this category, and this one was...I don't know, exactly. It was very good, except where he gave into her so easily. I can't see him just believing her after everything like that, not after he's had his heart ripped up. He's not a very careless man, and I think his own instinct would stop him from coming back to her...and therefore destroy him. But I already wrote a story about that, didn't I...?
Have you read the book? It gives a better understanding of the relationship between them, and into Rhett's characer in particular.
FaerieGirl2 8/9/03 . chapter 1
Wow, I love this story. Its short, but its not sudden like most of the other stories. Its informative, but not a drag.

Great work and you are a very talented writer _
salzstar 7/14/03 . chapter 1
An absolutely beautiful piece! I've just finished reading Gone with the Wind for the first time and was wholly unsatisfied with the ending - I mean, how could it just *end* like that? But after reading your fic I'm just going to pretend that this part was in the book... I absolutely loved this piece of writing :o).
twinsofthesky 6/20/03 . chapter 1
*dabs eyes* Just wonderful.

I love Gone with the Wind.

I love your fic.

*bursts into a torrent of tears*

It's beautiful!

*wail*

Well.. To get to the normal person I am..

Read 'Scarlett' by Alexandria Ripley.

Ah... So romantic.
Deeta 6/18/03 . chapter 1
MM...I'm dizzy. It's a totally lovely fiction!
Jem Black 1/26/03 . chapter 1
awww i liked that! I thought it was sad at the end when he left her!Even though she did kind of deserve it!
Young Republican 12/20/02 . chapter 1
I'm such a hopeless romantic and I positivly love Gone With The Wind, especially Rhett and Scarlett. I have to admit that while it was the movie that first got me interested, it was the book that captivated me. Anyway, about your story: completely awsome! It was so well written, every was just...it was almost like I was reading an epilogue by Mitchell herself. I would love to read anything else you wrote about GWTW! Please tell me where I can find more!
Kitty in the Box 11/27/02 . chapter 1
aaaaaaaahhhhhhhhh!

hehehe...sorry for screaming like that *cough, cough*

for awhile you really got me there, i completely thought these two were gonna break up and it's gonna be one of dem "deal with it tragedy" fics for me.

but it's not! it's not!

i'm just so happy to have read your work.
lilz 9/2/02 . chapter 1
ive never seen the movie of gone with the wind but i just read the book and it was really bugging me that they didn't stay 2gether at the end so, ur story is perfect :D
Alicia Jo Twain 8/25/02 . chapter 1
I quite liked it! It was too short tho, write some more! I loved the whole inner-Scarlett's-feelings thing.
Twixxa 8/20/02 . chapter 1
AWWWWWW! That was so sweet!

You captured Rhett and Scarlett's characters so so well... You must right more GWTW fanfic.

- Twixxa
pink sugar heart attack 7/31/02 . chapter 1
Loverly. How the movie shoulda ended. I liked the inter-splicing of past dialogue. . Hooray for Scarlett and Rhett!

Becca
GoddessVixen 7/19/02 . chapter 1
excellent story. it capture personalities of both Scarlett and Rhett perfectly.

i hope that some time soon that you write another story for the "Gone With

The Wind " catergory
17 found: Page 1 2 Next »
Return to Top