|
|
| Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search | Login Register Extras |
| Lilith_L2 2007-11-02 ch 1, anon. | abuseI think it's fantastic, It was more normal than the real story. Harry is unforgible with treason, then why always forgive Ron? Well done, congratulations. |
| GeT.a.FiSh. 2007-07-25 ch 1, | abuseAmazing story! The entire plot is outstanding. It's one of the best one-shots I've read in a long time. The problem with the date was small enough to feel finished but the story just hints towards the rest, but the large problem was there too - unfinished, but having the feeling that it has a solution that will come later. Then, of course, the dash of humor at the end. Just awesome. |
| LucifaelsBride 2007-05-26 ch 1, | abuseDo you want to know why this never happened in the book? Because in the book JK Rowling was trying to portray a real character, not a larger-than-life figure. You're just chanelling into your stories what you want yourself to be like. You want to be uber-powerful, you want every girl in town to want you, you want to have a gaze so powerful you could terrify a person with one look. And since you can't have it, you're portraying your desires into Harry/ Harry is a real teen with real teen problems. He's not some great hero who needs to be the center of attention. That's what you made him sound like in your story, where you make do that little soap opera with everyone watching. Harry is not like that...he's not all great and not everybody want him so badly it hurts...now that I think about, basically all you stories have girls hanging with thier mouths drooling after Harry. This is just mysogyny in disguise. What you really want to get through is that Harry is superior to everyone and everything... God I hate fanfics like this...you turn a really awesome story of a teen who is human and kind and forgiving into something like this where he believes that he's the only one that is hurt and that everyone has to go on their knees to apologize to him. You've never even considered Ron's point of view. You're just trying to portray him as a holier-than-thou male version of a Mary-Sue. This is not realistic in any sense of the word, rather it's uber-u Go to google...type in Mary Sue Litmus Test and take it. |
| alec-potter 2007-04-28 ch 1, | abusesweet...really really sweet...hope you update your other stories soon...best of luck... |
| madbrad 2007-03-26 ch 1, | abuseFor some reason I've always loved this story, coming back to re-read it every now and then. It embodies the lovely warm H/Hr feelings that are also in Backwards Compatible (which I hope one day you'll finish, although I guess - it's been fandom aeons since an update - the odds aren't good). Anyway, thanks again for this story. |
| tansy1354 2006-12-04 ch 1, | abuseI don't write many reviews but I just had to say how much I enjoyed your story. I believe it is a little more believable that the canon version and I also prefer the harry/hermione combination too. I am also glad that you had it take place in front of the other houses because it gave them a glimpse of what life is really like for the boy-who-lived. |
| HarmonyLovely 2006-11-28 ch 1, | abuseSo I was surfing around because I am bored out of my mind and I choose a random Harmony story to read...because we all know they are the best couple in HP...even if the sadly don't end up together. Anyway, back to the story, I love Ron and Harry's friendship...but there is a tiny part of me that hates their friendship. Because it should be both ways, where as sometimes, Harry seems to be the only one acting like a friend. I also love the Harry and Hermione fluff...I just love, love, love it! So even though this story was written forever ago...I still decided to leave a review. Rebbie |
| CRaZY TeDDy 2006-11-20 ch 1, | abuseIs that the end? Cause if it is it was pretty good. Though i don't like the fact he is going to forgive ron. If this isn't the end and you dont plan on writing more or if it is and you still dont plan on writing more i wouldnt mind giving it a shoot and finishing it. Course id change abit of it lol... or i might just make my own like this sep no ron forgiveness!! |
| kittydemon18 2006-11-14 ch 1, | abuselove it so far especially the end part "What!? Are you out of your mind!?" "More or less." i'm so going to have to figure out a way to use that in real life! update soon please! |
| jedipilot24 2006-11-08 ch 1, anon. | abuseLike this story, just one problem. They don't find out about the Yule Ball until two weeks after the First Task. |
| mathiasgranger 2006-11-03 ch 1, | abuseOh how I wish this is what had actually happened. I don't buy into the oh sure treat me like crap for a month, yeah I'll forgive you straight away. Frankly, Harry should have followed the left with a right to even things out. What a fun one shot. Thanks for writing, Matt |
| Rebel Goddess 2006-07-17 ch 1, | abuseI love that final punch. Once again you made me laugh my head off and I agree, it definitely could have gone that way. I think if Ron had acted that way in the fifth book it would have. Excellent. |
| deathstreet91 2006-01-29 ch 1, | abuseAwsome chap |
| greenfly 2006-01-02 ch 1, | abuseheh heh heh... Pansy. Wouldn't that be a sight to see... |
| Salazar Slytherin Snakes 2005-12-27 ch 1, | abuseI love this story please update. |